Graveyard Shift 10 Fan Theories And Predictions For 'Pet Sematary'  

Jacob Shelton
1.6k votes 440 voters 22.1k views 10 items

List Rules Vote up the most plausible fan theories.

While Stephen King fans patiently wait for the new Pet Sematary adaptation, we've gathered the best Pet Sematary fan theories and predictions. Starring Jason Clarke and John Lithgow, the Paramount film is likely to surprise and terrify viewers in the best possible way. It's not entirely clear how closely the new film will mirror the book, but many people have interesting theories and bold predictions for Pet Sematary.

As soon as the Pet Sematary trailers went viral, horror fans quickly began analyzing screenshots, hunting for clues, and trying to connect any dots they could find. When Pet Sematary hits theaters on April 5, 2019, we can finally see how many of those fan theories and predictions turned out right.

1 306 VOTES
Church Lures Ellie To Her Death
Church Lures Ellie To Her Deat... is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list 10 Fan Theories And Predictions For 'Pet Sematary'
Photo: Pet Sematary/Paramount

Following the release of the second trailer for Pet Semetary 2019, Redditor Gato1486 shared happiness about Church's role in the film. The contributor also thinks the new film will feature a big change. Specifically, the user predicts Church will lure Ellie to her death. The situation won't be an accident. They believe

They've done very right by Churchill. In the original he comes back and is instantly evil. In the book, he comes back, but unsettles the characters, though they can't put their finger on why. I love that they used him to lure Ellie to her apparent death here. I never really liked how Gage was able to outrun both his parents and get on the road in both the book and [first adaptation]. He's two. Realistically, he's not going to be very far from either parent's reach because of that. Ellie, being the older child expected to stay close to her parents and follow them, is a much more realistic target for the event that happens.

260 46
Do you buy this?
2 191 VOTES
It Will Set Up A Stephen King Cinematic Universe
It Will Set Up A Stephen King ... is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list 10 Fan Theories And Predictions For 'Pet Sematary'
Photo: Pet Sematary/Paramount Pictures

Stephen King fans on Twitter seem to think Pet Sematary will launch a cinematic universe for the author. Not only are many of King's stories connected through dense mythology, but a lot of the tales take place in Maine, just like the new film. 

When you see Pet Sematary in the theater, keep an eye out for any connective tissue between the film and other Stephen King's works. 

156 35
Do you buy this?
3 168 VOTES
There Will Be A Lot Of Information On The Lore And Mysticism
There Will Be A Lot Of Informa... is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list 10 Fan Theories And Predictions For 'Pet Sematary'
Photo: Twitter

While replying to a Twitter thread about what he thinks is going to happen in the upcoming adaptation of Pet Sematary, Twitter user Javier von Count mentioned the film might delve deeply into the mythology surrounding the Micmac burial ground. This is actually a pretty good idea.

That explanation might help explain exactly what's happening with the Creed family. Additionally, the second trailer for the film features a book that includes the Wendigo and other folklore, so this theory is pretty accurate.

140 28
Do you buy this?
4 157 VOTES
The Wendigo Will Play A Bigger Role
The Wendigo Will Play A Bigger... is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list 10 Fan Theories And Predictions For 'Pet Sematary'
Photo: Pet Sematary/Paramount

The 1989 adaptation of Pet Sematary doesn't heavily feature the Wendigo, a mythological Native American spirit that pushes the people of Ludlow to bury their dead in the Micmac burial ground. Redditor PrimariumZ11 believes the new film adaptation will, though. They wrote

Will the Wendigo be incorporated more in the 2019 film? That is honestly too tough to say, but it is more likely than not. [Adaptations] give filmmakers a chance to look at certain, unexplored aspects of the source material while still following the same basic story... a few good expamples would be the empowerment of Barbara in the 1990 version of Night of the Living Dead and the linear storytelling and the inclusion of the Neibolt St house in the 2017 version of It... not to mention the modernisation of the timelines to make the pieces more relevant today. So in conclusion, I do believe the Wendigo is going to be an aspect explored more in the 2019 [adaptation].

127 30
Do you buy this?