Total Nerd
121 voters

Ranking Every Captain America in the Comics

Updated October 13, 2018 1.2k votes 121 voters 1.7k views31 items

List RulesUpvote the best comic book characters who have been Captain America

We’re ranking every Captain America in the Marvel comics universe. Along with all Captain America incarnations that appeared in the comic books, this list also includes alternate versions as well as villains who became Captain America. Who is your favorite Captain America?

Everyone knows the original Cap Steve Rogers, but did you know there have been several black Captain Americas and female Captain Americas? Several enemies have even worn the suit and used the Captain America alias, like Red Skull, Pitt'o Nili, and Frank Simpson. Other comic book characters who were Captain America include Cyclops, Winter Soldier, and Punisher. 

Vote for the best Captain America in comics. This ranking of every Captain America displays pictures of the characters in costume and their comic book appearances. 

Photo:
...more
  • 1
    94
    6

    Steve Rogers

    Captain America Comics, Avengers
    Captain America is a fictional superhero appearing in American comic books published by Marvel...  more

    More Captain America 

    #157 of 319 The Greatest Cartoon Characters in TV History#7 of 297 The Best Comic Book Superheroes Of All Time

  • 2
    48
    26

    Bucky Barnes

    Captain America Vol 5
    Bucky is the name of several fictional characters that were masked superheroes in the Marvel...  more

    More Bucky Barnes 

    15 Fan Theories About Bucky Barnes That Are Wild Enough To Be True#6 of 13 The Best Villainous Reveals In The MCU, Ranked

  • 3
    42
    35

    Sam Wilson

    Captain America Vol 7
    Falcon (Samuel Thomas Wilson) is a fictional superhero appearing in American comic books...  more

    More Sam Wilson (Falcon) 

    #13 of 15 Famous Superheroes Whose Powers Don’t Work The Way You Think#26 of 26 The 25 Strongest Superheroes In The MCU, Ranked

  • 4
    22
    21

    Samantha Wilson

    Spider-Gwen
  • 5
    15
    19

    Captain Ape-Merica

    Marvel Apes
  • 6
    14
    18

    Frank Simpson

    Ultimate Comics Captain America
  • 7
    17
    23

    Isaiah Bradley

    Truth: Red, White & Black
    Isaiah Bradley is a fictional character in the Marvel Comics universe, an early product of the...  more
  • 8
    25
    36

    John Walker

    Captain America
    U.S. Agent is a fictional comic book superhero appearing in books published by Marvel Comics,...  more

    More U.S. Agent 

    #41 of 50 The Most Ridiculous Superheroes Ever#62 of 68 The Greatest Marvel Avengers Characters Of All Time

  • 9
    13
    19

    Roscoe Simons

    Captain America
  • 10
    18
    26

    Jeffrey Mace

    Captain America
    Jeffrey Solomon "Jeff" Mace, also known as the Patriot and Captain America, is a fictional...  more
  • 11
    12
    18

    Ava

    What If? Age of Ultron

    More 

    #241 of 262 The Greatest Female Villains#57 of 84 The Best Pet Names Of All Time

  • 12
    14
    22

    Steven Rogers (Revolutionary War)

    Captain America: Sentinel Of Liberty
  • 13
    22
    34

    Frank Castle

    Marvel What If?
    The Punisher (Francis "Frank" Castle, born Castiglione) is a fictional character appearing in...  more

    More Punisher 

    The Best Punisher Storylines To Get To Know Frank Castle#488 of 1,297 The Greatest TV Characters of All Time

  • 14
    7
    12

    Robert Russo

    Captain America
  • 15
    7
    13

    Scar Turpin

    Captain America
  • 16
    15
    25

    Shannon Carter

    What If? Age of Ultron
  • 17
    15
    26

    Scott Summers

    Ultimate X-Men Fantastic Four Annual
    Cyclops is a fictional superhero appearing in American comic books published by Marvel Comics...  more

    More Cyclops 

    #54 of 187 The Top Marvel Comics Superheroes#795 of 3,511 The Best Movie Characters Of All Time

  • 18
    17
    29

    Carol Danvers

    New Mangaverse: The Rings of Fate
    Carol Danvers is a fictional character, a superhero that appears in comic books published by...  more

    More Captain Marvel (Carol Danvers) 

    Fan Theories About Captain Marvel That Actually Make A Lot Of SenseExactly How Strong Is Captain Marvel?

  • 19
    13
    25

    Danielle Cage

    Avengers: Ultron Forever
  • 20
    13
    25

    William Nasland

    Captain America
  • 21
    13
    26

    Roberta Mendez

    Secret Wars 2099
  • 22
    4
    13

    Steve Mouser

    Marvel Tails Starring Peter Porker the Spectacular Spider-Ham
  • 23
    6
    16

    Elijah Bradley

    Avengers: The Children's Crusade - Young Avengers
  • 24
    10
    22

    William Burnside

    Captain America
  • 25
    5
    15

    David Rickford

    Captain America