The Real Reasons Why Your Favorite TV Shows Were Canceled  

Jacob Shelton
882.8k views 17 items

As hundreds of television shows premiere every year, it’s obvious many of them will fail – even the good ones. We’ve all felt the pain of our favorite underdog show being ripped away from us before we get closure about the time traveling ghost dog, or college kids who solve mysteries (or whatever). Fear not fellow viewers, we’ve tracked down the hard answers to why popular shows get canceled and laid them out here for you. Now rip off that band-aid and read about why your favorite show got canceled.

The only people who know why shows get canceled are the executives who end up pulling the plug on the program. Most viewers believe that low ratings is the only way for a show to disappear, but there are plenty of reasons why shows get canceled, and we’ve got plenty of them here. Some shows had concepts that were too complicated, while others weren’t “on brand.” And that’s just scratching the surface of why your favorite show was taken off the air.

After you finish reading about why your favorite shows were canceled, take to the comments and tell us what you think would have saved the show. 

Brooklyn Nine-Nine is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list The Real Reasons Why Your Favorite TV Shows Were Canceled
Photo:  Brooklyn Nine-Nine/Fox Television/Amazon/Fair Use

In a surprise move, Fox abruptly canceled Brooklyn Nine-Nine after five seasons in May 2018. The network did not give a reason for the cancelation, but some outlets speculated it could have been axed to make room for another night of football programming. 

Universal Television produced the series; Deadline suggested contract negotiations with the outside production company might have gone south.

More Brooklyn Nine-Nine

#6 of 154 on The Best TV Shows Returning In 2019 #4 of 116 on The Best TV Shows Streaming On Hulu featuring The Best Episodes Of 'Brooklyn Nine-Nine' The Best Characters On 'Brooklyn Nine-Nine'

see more on Brooklyn Nine-Nine
Penny Dreadful is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list The Real Reasons Why Your Favorite TV Shows Were Canceled
Photo:  Penny Dreadful/Showtime/Amazon/Fair Use

Encapsulating the tragically beautiful spirit of the whole series, Penny Dreadful ended with hope, despair, and more than a little shock. During the third season finale, hearts broke over the selfless passing of Vanessa Ives (Eva Green) and emotions blazed when the words "The End" marked the unexpected ending to the series.

As to why exactly Penny Dreadful was canceled, series creator John Logan simply felt it was the right thing to do for the story. He explained: "To me, the show was always going to achieve closure with the death of Vanessa. And all the storylines this season were meant to be leaving characters at a place of appropriate and beautiful stasis." With its poetic ending, Penny Dreadful fans will undoubtedly remember their favorite characters in the final moments Logan created for them.

More Penny Dreadful

#29 of 131 on The Best of Premium Cable TV Series #96 of 298 on The Best Sci Fi Television Series of All Time #24 of 406 on TV Shows That Only Smart People Appreciate featuring 12 Easter Eggs In 'Penny Dreadful' Designed For Brainy Viewers

see more on Penny Dreadful
Firefly is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list The Real Reasons Why Your Favorite TV Shows Were Canceled
Photo:  Firefly/Fox/Amazon/Fair Use

In hindsight, it's probably good that Firefly was canceled. After all, we got Serenity and two rad Avengers movies out of the death of the space western that could. But why was it canceled? Sadly, Joss Whedon's one time producing partner Gail Berman had to cancel the show because of poor ratings.

“It was a numbers thing. It was a wonderful show and I loved it and I loved working with him on it but that was a big show, a very expensive show and it wasn’t delivering the numbers.”

More Firefly

#33 of 762 on The Best TV Shows to Binge Watch #42 of 1116 on The Greatest TV Shows Of All Time featuring 14 Fun Facts About Joss Whedon's 'Firefly' Even Diehard Fans Don't Know 13 Crazy Yet Plausible Fan Theories About Firefly

see more on Firefly
Veronica Mars is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list The Real Reasons Why Your Favorite TV Shows Were Canceled
Photo:  Veronica Mars/The CW/Amazon/Fair Use

In 2007, Veronica Mars was one of the only shows with an intelligent female protagonist, so it seems short-sighted to cancel it. It had a huge fan base that was continuing to grow, and has become something of a cult classic even today. 

Series creator Rob Thomas shed some light on the early end of the series, saying that after he pitched a variation of the show, the head of CBS decided the format didn't work and took the show off the air. 

More Veronica Mars

#55 of 762 on The Best TV Shows to Binge Watch #34 of 289 on The Best Cult TV Shows of All Time featuring 21 Things You Didn't Know About Veronica Mars Favorite Character in iZombie

see more on Veronica Mars