22 Fascinating Stories From Men Who Proposed And She Said 'No'

Voting Rules
Vote up the craziest stories.

It's not all moonlight and roses. Sometimes your gut stops you from making a huge mistake. Sometimes a marriage proposal is all wrong.

Photo: u/FeloniousFelon / Reddit

  • 1
    1,541 VOTES

    Bullet Dodged

    From Redditor u/Nemrodh:

    I was a young Marine. I was only home during the weekends. was dating this girl for about a year from my home town.

    When I asked she said yes.

    Her dad former Navy kept saying we should wait. We put it off for a bit longer.

    Fast forward another year. she dumped me. Father informs me she has been sleeping with A LOT of guys.. like more then 50 over the 2 yrs we dated. And was very happy i didn't marry her. and apologizes to me for her behavior.

    She then totally ghosting everyone including her family for about 6 months. Find out she moved 7 hrs away and was living under a house.. not a basement. under a house with her new bf... She calls her mom to come get her. Mother and father ask me to go get her and bring her home..

    Good times.. good times.

    1,541 votes
  • 2
    2,518 VOTES

    Worse Than Ross And Rachel!

    From Redditor u/ThePeasantKingM:

    Oh I have a story about this.

    My friend A had been with his girlfriend B for years, so he decided he wanted to propose. What he didn't know, is that B was also thinking about proposing to him.

    A proposed first, and B freaked out because she had already set her proposal and bought a ring, so she said no. Over the next week, B freaked out more and more, and refused to answer A's calls and messages.

    A then decided to use the money he had saved up to buy a plane ticket to Europe. What was supposed to be a 3 month trip through western Europe turned out to be a year long trip around the world.

    One day, A says that he's coming back and B decides to go and wait for him at the airport and propose to him there. It turns out that while being in Peru, A met a girl and they fell in love almost immediately, and got married in Peru.

    Cue 5 years later, A and his Peruvian wife are still happily married and recently had a baby, while B hasn't still quite forgiven herself for ruining her relationship with A.

    2,518 votes
  • 3
    2,006 VOTES

    The Biggest Regret

    From Redditor u/freetraveler11:

    I was the one who said no.

    We were high school sweethearts - had actually known each other since first grade and despite me moving to a different city, we reconnected in high school.

    I followed him out to college and realized there was a whole other world out there besides the small towns I grew up in.

    He already had our entire life planned out and it wasn’t until we had dated 3 1/2 years and he “surprised” me with a ring and a proposal that I realized he wasn’t what I wanted at all. He was lazy, never went to class, didn’t stand up for himself, and was codependent.

    I said no.

    He then proceeded to literally stalk me. We lived in the same apartment complex, but different units. He would knock on my door all hours of the day. I never answered. He would call and text constantly. This was before you could block numbers on an iPhone.

    He attempted to break in to my roommates window and was successful because she had left it unlocked. I wasn’t at the apartment and he told her, “I was just trying to get some stuff”.

    The very rare occasions I would open the door (very shortly after our break up), he would force his way in or stick his boot in between the door so I couldn’t close it.

    I called the cops numerous times but they never did anything.

    He would follow me if I left places.

    At one point, he somehow knew information that I knew he COULDNT have known and found out he had somehow installed a program onto my computer to track all my passwords and keystrokes and activity.

    That was when I decided to change my phone number.

    He would leave stuff on our balcony. Letters, gifts, random sh*t.

    He did not stop and would threaten me often by saying he would find out my new phone number.

    Eventually, it did get less and less, however TO THIS DAY, I still hear from him.

    I’m married now (for almost 4 years) and I’ve heard that he is also married and has a kid on the way.

    But a few months ago, he found my extremely obscure Facebook (it’s not even my full name. It’s half my first name and only my middle name. I have maybe 11 “friends” on there that he has no connection with. I really only use this fb to be in groups to discuss true crime) and asked me to meet up with him for lunch for closure. I blocked him, but I know I’ll hear from him again somehow in a few months.

    It’s ridiculous, honestly. I regret ever dating the guy.

    2,006 votes
  • 4
    1,388 VOTES

    It Could Be Worse

    From Redditor u/yathisisafakeone:

    We were dating for a little over a year but I was so sure she was the one. I drove 2 hours to see her at her college and went on a beautiful winter night walk and proposed. She looks me right in the eyes and said, “Oh you thought this was serious? Well um I don’t know how to say this other than I have been seeing other people. Well actually I have been seeing other women.” I was stunned I got up put the ring in my pocket and walked to my car got in and drove away never looking back crying the whole time. Haven’t seen or spoken with her in 7 years even though she has tried countless times to reach out. Now it’s a story I tell friends who are nervous about asking their significant others to marry them. Reminding them that even if they say no it could be worse

    1,388 votes
  • 5
    1,863 VOTES

    Ti Amo

    From Redditor u/PazzaCiccio:

    My mother told my father no three times. On the third time he got wasted at a local bar and basically started pouring his heart out to any one who’d listen. Mind you, it’s a very small village in the Italian alps and my father barely spoke Italian and no one in the village spoke English, including my mother. Word got back to my mom about this sad American at the bar so she went to find him and she told him she’d marry him.

    My parents celebrated their 44th anniversary last month.

    1,863 votes
  • 6
    1,450 VOTES

    Unhung Hero

    From Redditor u/ObscureCulturalMeme:

    So this actor, Patrick Moote, proposes to his girlfriend at a basketball game and gets turned down... while on the giant jumbotron. Clip goes on youtube, etc, etc.

    She tells him later that she turned him down because she thinks his d*** is too small. So he travels around the world, documenting what other cultures think about penis size and penis enlargement, and made a movie about it called Unhung Hero. I've never watched it, but the title alone makes me laugh.

    1,450 votes