Plausible Fan Theories About Riverdale's Murder Mystery 

Justin Andress
Updated June 14, 2019 5.8k votes 1k voters 30.7k views 13 items

List Rules Vote up the theories that seem the most plausible.

Riverdale is yet another soapy CW drama featuring attractive high schoolers. But in this show, the world of classic Archie comics gets a campy update that's more Gossip Girl than Happy Days. The Riverdale Archie is much more brooding and mysterious than his comic book inspiration, and the show follows suit with its twisting, David Lynch-inspired mysteries. In short, with Riverdale the CW has created a show that's instantly addictive.

The premise alone will catch your eye: Jason Blossom, the most popular boy in school, has been murdered. And that's just the tip of the iceberg when it comes to the secrets boiling just under the town’s surface. Like any TV mystery, viewers are beginning to come up with their own ideas about what exactly happened to Jason Blossom. Fan theories about Riverdale range from the plausible (Jason's twin Cheryl killed him) to the outrageous (the whole thing is a set-up for a zombie-themed future season).

Whether Riverdale makes you roll your eyes or scoot to the edge of your seat, it's fun to read some of the craziest fan theories out there. Keep scrolling to discover just what viewers think is happening on this show.

Data-driven recommendations based on voting from over 40 million monthly visits to Ranker. Try the free app
The Blossoms Murdered Jason
The Blossoms Murdered Ja... is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list Plausible Fan Theories About Riverdale's Murder Mystery
Photo:  The CW

The Blossoms may not have killed Jason directly, but they could have hired someone to do it. Penelope has threatened Cheryl’s life before, and she and her husband seem so tightly wound that it's possible that one or both of them flew off the handle on finding Jason gone.

Did the parents track down their son and have him killed? Maybe - and it doesn't seem unlike the Blossoms to use Jason's body as a lesson for Cheryl, either.

Is this plausible?
Archie Was The Intended Target All Along
Archie Was The Intended ... is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list Plausible Fan Theories About Riverdale's Murder Mystery
Photo:  The CW

Maybe Riverdale's erstwhile central character refuses to take the spotlight because he knows he’s in someone’s crosshairs. After all, he was at Sweetwater River on the day of Jason's murder, too. And as Mrs. Blossom notes, Archie and Jason do kind of look alike. What if Jason simply got caught in the crossfire when someone was actually planning to take out Archie?

Perhaps Ms. Grundy told the truth about her abusive ex, and he's on the hunt to murder her current lover. Or maybe Ms. Grundy didn’t want Archie around anymore and mistook Jason for him. Either way, it's interesting to consider whether Archie was meant to be murdered all along.

Is this plausible?
Sabrina Will Show Up
Sabrina Will Show Up is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list Plausible Fan Theories About Riverdale's Murder Mystery
Photo:  Archie Comics

The comparisons between David Lynch’s Twin Peaks and the CW’s Riverdale have run rampant since the show's debut. Both shows take place in small towns, follow kids who are way too adult for their age, and both have something to say about the American Dream.

But there is one big difference. In Twin Peaks (spoiler alert), the killer was an evil demon. There was a portal to another dimension where people spoke in reverse. In other words, the supernatural existed. That isn’t the case in Riverdale yet. However, should the showrunners want to get a little witchy, Archie Comics already has a built-in candidate: the white-haired witch, Sabrina.

Is this plausible?
Archie Has A Secret Plan
Archie Has A Secret Plan... is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list Plausible Fan Theories About Riverdale's Murder Mystery
Photo:  The CW

While Veronica, Betty, Jughead, and the rest of the gang are caught up in the central mystery of the series, Archie has spent his time sleeping with his teacher and balancing music lessons with football. He’s got to be up to something - if only because otherwise, the ostensible star of the show is its weakest character.

Is this plausible?