Graveyard Shift

16 Horror Movies That Lead to Real-Life Death  

Christopher Shultz
5.6k votes 1.2k voters 198.2k views 16 items

List Rules Vote up the most terrible story of a killer movie

"To avoid fainting, keep repeating: 'It's only a movie, only a movie, only a movie...'" reads the tagline to Wes Craven's exploitative horror film The Last House on the Left. For the most part, horror movies are just that: pieces of narrative fiction that only harm the average person by giving them nightmares.

And yet, there are some horror movies that have actually lead to deaths in the real world. This in and of itself might sound like the plot to a film (and indeed, this is the exact plot to John Carpenter's Cigarette Burns), but there are a few instances of films being so terrifying they left people literally scared to death. In other cases, the plots and characters of various films inspired disturbed minds to commit horrific murders. You'll find instances of both in this list of 16 horror movies that lead to real-life deaths.

The Collector is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list 16 Horror Movies That Lead to Real-Life Death
Photo:  The Collector/Columbia Pictures
The 1965 film The Collector (based on a book by John Fowles) - about a man whose obsession with a woman leads him to kidnapping and imprisoning her in his cellar - reportedly inspired serial killer Leonard Lake. Alongside his murderous accomplice Charles Ng, Lake initiated "Operation Miranda," named after the woman in The Collector, whereby he and Ng kidnapped, tortured, and killed Brenda O'Connor and Kathy Allen in a sound-proof bunker.
Is this scary?
see more on The Collector
Saw VI is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list 16 Horror Movies That Lead to Real-Life Death
Photo:  SAW 6/Lionsgate
In 2013, UK resident Matthew Tinling murdered his neighbor Richard Hamilton by stabbing him 17 times in the legs, head, and neck. The latter area of Hamilton's body underwent the most extensive carnage, as Tinling, inspired by a scene in Saw VI, attempted to slice through the man's spinal chord.

More Saw VI

#25 of 136 on The Goriest Movies Ever Made #47 of 99 on The Best Horror Movie Sequels #61 of 212 on Movies Turning 10 in 2019 featuring The Best Saw Characters in the Whole Franchise, Ranked

Is this scary?
see more on Saw VI
Halloween is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list 16 Horror Movies That Lead to Real-Life Death
Photo:  Halloween/MGM
Jake Evans, then 17 years old, killed his mother and teenage sister on October 3, 2012, inside their Aledo, Texas, home. In his confession, Evans wrote that Rob Zombie's 2007 remake of Halloween gave him inspiration for his own killing. He states, "While watching it I was amazed at how at ease the boy [12-year-old Michael Myers] was during the murders and how little remorse he had afterword [sic]. I was thinking to myself it would be the same for me when I kill someone."

More Halloween

#16 of 33 on Horror Movie Reboots No One Ever Asked For #7 of 11 on Every Movie in the Halloween Franchise, Ranked Best to Worst #12 of 136 on The Goriest Movies Ever Made #14 of 27 on 27 Films Stephen King Has Awarded His Personal Stamp Of Approval

Is this scary?
see more on Halloween
Queen of the Damned is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list 16 Horror Movies That Lead to Real-Life Death
Photo:  Queen of the Damned/Warner Bros.

In 2004, Alan Menzies of West Lothian, Scotland, developed an obsession with the box-office failure Queen of the Damned, a sequel to Interview with the Vampire. He reportedly watched the film over 100 times in a few short months. In particular, he believed one of the film's characters, Akasha (played by the late Aaliyah) was real and was communicating with him.  

When his friend Thomas McKendrick confronted him about his obsession, Menzies claims Akasha ordered him to kill McKendrick in her honor, which he did. Menzies later killed himself in jail.

More Queen of the Damned

#25 of 51 on Every Movie Coming To Netflix In December 2019 #64 of 106 on The Greatest Directorial Debuts Of All Time #43 of 50 on Life-Changing Documentaries You've Got to See #25 of 38 on The Most Woke Movies of All Time

Is this scary?
see more on Queen of the Damned