vote on everything
Graveyard Shift
510 voters

Non R-Rated Horror Movies As Scary As Anything

Updated February 21, 2020 4.6k votes 510 voters 14.5k views15 items

List RulesVote up the horror movies that are terrifying without relying on R-rated gore.

Everyone remembers the first movie that terrified them into a sleepless night (or week) of hiding under the blankets and praying for the sun to come up. Sometimes that movie was disguised as a family-friendly feature; other times, your parents saw the PG rating and decided because it lacked intense scenes or other mature themes that it would be juuust fine. Either way, those PG or PG-13 scary movies made a lasting impression. Maybe they scarred you for life, or maybe they turned you into a lifelong horror fan.

While horror masters like Eli Roth and Rob Zombie use grotesque imagery to intensify their disturbing tales, less inspired scary movies tend to rely a little too heavily on blood and gore to scare audiences. To the unvetted viewer, this grossness overload can be off-putting, and for the desensitized horror junkie, the lack of plot simply makes for a boring movie.

There are a number of cinematic gems in the horror genre that make particularly good use of tension, oppressive atmosphere, high stakes, intriguing characters, and downright creepy situations to create a truly horrifying experience that stays with you long after the credits have rolled. Here is a list of the best PG-13 horror movies (and one PG horror movie!) that are sure to haunt you.

  • If you weren’t already scared of Tiny Tim before you saw Insidious, this movie will seal the deal. James Wan’s Insidious is a wild, heart-pounding ride that expertly preys on both realistic and supernatural fears alike.

    After being antagonized by paranormal events in their new home, a family’s youngest son falls into a coma for no apparent reason. After doing some digging and teaming up with a group of demonologists, they discover his spirit was captured by a demon while the boy astral projected in dreams. The “Lipstick-Face Demon,” as he’s called, looks like Darth Maul’s feral cousin who's been left under the care of Freddy Krueger.

    As they struggle to recover the boy’s soul, the family must endure several terrifying encounters with a group of ghosts that flock to their home. These spirits attempt to break into their bedroom at night; the baby monitor echoes with threatening sounds; and the mother is teased by the giggling ghost of a young boy as Tiny Tim’s music plays of its own accord. Finally, they are forced to travel beyond the boundaries of normal horror movies in the stunning third act. Enjoy the Pavlovian fear response to “Tiptoe Through the Tulips” for the rest of your life!

    • Actors: Rose Byrne, Barbara Hershey, Patrick Wilson, Lin Shaye, Leigh Whannell
    • Released: 2010
    • Directed by: James Wan
    371
    59
    Scary?

    More Insidious 

    #76 of 242 The Best Psychological Thrillers of All Time#16 of 714 The Best Horror Movies Of All Time#7 of 114 The Best Intelligent Horror Movies

    amazon buy button
  • Naomi Watts stars in this bone-chilling horror classic directed by Gore Verbinski. This movie contains some deeply disturbing imagery that focuses on unsettling the viewer psychologically.

    Rachel (Watts) is investigating her niece’s sudden passing when she discovers a VHS tape of unknown origin. On it is a series of bizarre and frightening images, including a cord being drawn out of someone’s throat, maggots transforming into humans, and the titular ring of light. After watching this video, Rachel receives a phone call warning her that she will perish in seven days. The tape’s content alone is enough to haunt the viewer, but things only get creepier from there. Rachel, now cursed, experiences a series of blood-curdling encounters and eventually tracks down the source of the tape to a young girl named Samara.

    The Ring’s cleverness lies in just how much it decides to reveal. We never learn exactly where Samara came from or how she could make a series of disturbing "pictures" with her mind, but we are given enough of her story to both fear and empathize with her. It is this limiting of information in the exact right amounts that manipulates our fear of the unknown and impossible.

    • Actors: Naomi Watts, Pauley Perrette, Brian Cox, Amber Tamblyn, Sara Rue
    • Released: 2002
    • Directed by: Gore Verbinski
    344
    88
    Scary?
    amazon buy button
  • The fact that this movie snuck by with a PG rating and still manages to be one of the scariest horror movies of all time speaks to its success. This is the ultimate haunted house film that contains a weird mixture of supernatural confusion, an evil clown doll, eerie spirits, face-ripping madness, and a totally out-of-control ending sequence that will leave you rattled.

    Poltergeist employs a familiar horror premise - a middle-class family in a haunted home dealing with ever-more-frequent paranormal events - but the stakes are immediately raised when the young daughter, Carol Anne, is abducted by ghosts and taken to a spirit world. The family must go through hell to retrieve their child and figure out why these restless souls are lashing out in the first place.

    So many of the spooky scenes in the movie make use of convincing practical effects that have aged well - particularly in an era oversaturated with CGI. 

    • Actors: Craig T. Nelson, JoBeth Williams, Heather O'Rourke, Zelda Rubinstein, Beatrice Straight
    • Released: 1982
    • Directed by: Tobe Hooper
    336
    92
    Scary?

    More Poltergeist 

    Did Steven Spielberg Really Ghost-Direct ‘Poltergeist’?#743 of 1,647 The Most Rewatchable Movies#257 of 355 The Best Rainy Day Movies

    amazon buy button
  • Based on the Japanese film Ju-On: The Grudge, this is the story of an angry spirit who exacts her revenge on the living. Told in a jarring and nonlinear style, it leaves the viewer feeling highly disoriented as various characters are hunted by one of the strangest ghosts in cinema. Kayako’s spirit appears as a sickly pale woman with stringy black hair covering her gaping eyes. An ominous gurgling, croaking sound heralds her appearances, and as the darkness grows, her specter emerges from the gloom to close in on her victims.

    Despite the convoluted story, this movie packs some serious scare sequences that evoke the slow, thick frustration of having a nightmare and being unable to move to escape peril. The way that Kayako’s ghost twitches and undulates adds to her unearthly, unstoppable terror. She cannot be contained, and the protagonists' helplessness is shared by the viewer - and lingers even after the film is done.

    • Actors: Sarah Michelle Gellar, KaDee Strickland, Bill Pullman, Rosa Blasi, Jason Behr
    • Released: 2004
    • Directed by: Takashi Shimizu
    313
    89
    Scary?
    amazon buy button
FilmsFilmEntertainmentHorrorHorror Movies and TVGraveyard Shift