By definition horror movies are meant to be frightening. They’re a safe trip into the depths of the subconscious, a place to explore the worst the imagination can offer. But every once in a while a filmmaker shoots a scene that they later realize is so disturbing the audience will feel jarred out of the "safety" of the film. A situation that leaves viewers feeling repulsed rather than delightfully spooked. In terms of art less is more, and the directors of horror movies with disturbing deleted scenes recognized that back to back scenes of mutilation and terror aren't enjoyable.
Part of the filmmaking process is shooting more footage than a director may actually end up using in the final edit. Despite the difficulty and risks of filming and the excruciating effort that goes into making movies, its just worth it to have more to work with. This maximalist approach is why these scenes that were too scary for horror movies exist.
For the horror film enthusiast who always wants more, these gruesome cut scenes are like delayed icing on the blood-soaked cake. Read on to discover some of the worst scenes cut from horror movies and think about whether or not they should have made it into the final cut. And, if you love all things spooky, check out this list of the scariest shows on television.
A Serbian Film, directed by Srđan Spasojević, is one of the most disturbing collection of scenes committed to film. The film is a reaction to the glut of foreign funded eastern European films of the time that Spasojević felt pushed politically correct agendas. A Serbian Film is quite the opposite and may just make you want to bleach your brain after viewing.
The movie follows Miloš, a former porn star who's offered a massive pay day for one last film. He reluctantly accepts and what follows is a descent into rape, torture, necrophilia, and child abuse. So what could the producers have possibly cut out of the movie? According to the British Board of Film Classification just over four minutes of child rape and sexualized depictions of children were cut from the film. The uncut version of A Serbian Film is out there to view, but why would you want to?
It's interesting that the producers behind a movie like The Human Centipede 2 would even bother sending the film to a ratings board to have it deemed watchable. The film features a character kidnapping a group of people, removing their teeth, and surgically stapling them together mouth to unmentionables to form a human centipede.
It's horrifying enough to watch humans forced to consume each other's feces, what could be worse? Rape of course. In a cut scene the character Martin wraps his penis in barbed wire and rapes the tail end of the centipede. The film was allowed to go to theaters once that scene was cut. But don't worry, it was re-inserted into the film for the US version of the unrated director's cut DVD and Blu-Ray. The entire franchise is obviously not for the casual horror movie watcher.
Paul W.S. Anderson's Event Horizon is an often overlooked science-fiction/horror film that teases an Alien-like monster on a spaceship narrative before descending into pure Lovecraftian terror. After docking on a spaceship sending out a distress signal the crew begins suffering from violent hallucinations. A major point of the film is when the crew finds a video log from the original crew's descent into the hell dimension. Even though the audience only sees a few seconds of the footage the message is plenty potent.
In the 20 seconds that appear in the final version of Event Horizon the audience is treated to writhing naked bodies, crew members eating each other alive, a guy being sodomized with a pipe, and another ripping out his own intestines through his mouth. According to effects supervisor Danny Bonnywell, Anderson actually filmed way more intense stuff even though he was pretty sure it would end up on the cutting room floor.
The simulated rape that Anderson filmed in the deleted version of the scene was allegedly so intense that he hired adult performers to make everything more realistic. Aside from that, there were shots of a crewmember's legs getting crushed, someone having screws drilled into their teeth, and a woman's breasts being ripped off. This additional footage is lost to time, however, and should probably stay lost.
#82 on The Best Movies of 1997
Some deleted scenes help to inform a character. For instance, if the scene of Darth Vader force choking a guy in Star Wars: A New Hope had been left on the cutting room floor, the audience would still know he was a villain, just not quite how ruthless he could be. Pennywise, the killer clown from It, doesn't need much backstory to prove that he's a monster. When he first appears in the film he literally pokes his head out of the sewer (bad guy character note 1) before ripping a child's arm off and dragging him into the sewer.
Apparently It's filmmakers weren't sure if audiences would fully understand the depths of Pennywise's depravity and originally meant to have a flashback scene where Pennywise forces a woman to choose between letting him eat her baby or having him destroy the entire community. Watching Pennywise prey on a group of teenagers is bad enough, watching him devour an infant would have been over the line.