15 Love Songs You Never Realized Are Super Dark And Creepy  

Matt Manser
22.1k votes 4.4k voters 218.3k views 15 items

List Rules Vote up the spookiest songs.

Ever sing along to a love song? Of course you have – they all seem so super sweet or achingly sad in a way that is totally beautiful and relatable. Well, you may want to rethink your feelings about some of those tunes after you see this list of love songs you never realized are creepy. Hits by artists like Adele, the Beatles, and more seem innocent on the surface, but when you really listen to the lyrics, you realize these are actually love songs with dark messages. Who knew so many songs about love were actually about stalking an ex or being attracted to people who are underage?

That's not to say these songs aren't great; many of them are classics for a reason. But there are lots of fun pop songs with dark meanings, when you think about it These secretly creepy love songs don't mean what you think they do. Take a listen, but you've been warned – this list might just ruin slow dances for you forever.

Every Breath You Take By The Police
Ranker Video
Video: YouTube

Sure, you can think of "Every Breath You Take" as a romantic ditty about a devoted lover. But when you pay attention to lyrics like, "Every move you make, every vow you break, every smile you fake, every claim you stake, I'll be watching you," the song takes a dark turn. It sounds more like a guy who got dumped and is now stalking his ex.

Even Sting knows "Every Breath You Take" is creepy. He said in an interview that the song references governments spying on their citizens, and that it's meant to be "very, very sinister and ugly."

More Every Breath You Take

#35 of 95 on The Best Songs With Breath in the Title #9 of 26 on What Was The Biggest Song The Year You Were Born?

Is this dark?
Ranker Video
Video: YouTube

This is one of DMB's best-known songs, thanks to its mellow hook and gentle vocals. It's swoon-worthy – until you listen to the lyrics, which include creepy lines like, "Hike up your skirt a little more and show your world to me," and, "Oh I watch you there through the window and I stare at you, you wear nothing but you wear it so well."

It just goes to show that if you have a sweet, soothing melody, even a song about a peeping Tom can be a hit.

More Crash Into Me

#12 of 14 on Classic '90s Middle School Dance Songs That Were Totally About Getting Busy #18 of 20 on Things Turning 20 in 2016 That Will Make You Feel Super Old #88 of 103 on The Best Rock Songs Of The '90s, Ranked #13 of 81 on The Best Dave Matthews Band Songs

Is this dark?
see more on Crash Into Me
Ranker Video
Video: YouTube

There are many things you can say to try to woo the person you're attracted to. You could say, "I can't imagine my life with anyone else but you," or, "You're the only person who has made me feel this way before." But, in general, a phrase to avoid is, "Let me be your father figure, put your tiny hand in mine."

Apparently no one told George Michael; that's the central motif of "Father Figure."

More Father Figure

#46 of 53 on The Best Blue-Eyed Soul Songs #2 of 83 on The Best Songs with Father in the Title #6 of 94 on The Best Songs About Family

Is this dark?
see more on Father Figure
I Will Possess Your Heart By Death Cab For Cutie
Ranker Video
Video: YouTube

In general, if someone says they want to possess you (or even just a part of you), it's probably not a good sign – even if they're the floppy haired nice guys of Death Cab for Cutie. The lyrics to "I Will Possess Your Heart" contain skin crawling lines like, "There are days when outside your window, I see my reflection as I slowly pass."

In other words, it's probably time to look into getting a restraining order.

More I Will Possess Your Heart

#69 of 106 on The Best Songs with Will in the Title #13 of 29 on The Best Songs About Stalkers #9 of 73 on The Best Death Cab For Cutie Songs

Is this dark?