Family Beloved Family Classics That Are Chock-Full Of Tragedy  

Jordan Breeding
4.1k votes 1k voters 30.6k views 12 items

List Rules Vote up the movies that you never realized are total tear-jerkers.

There's nothing quite like a good, wholesome family movie to help you unwind after a long day. Luckily, Hollywood cranks out an endless stream of films designed to fill audience's hearts and CEO's wallets. With so many movies coming out, its easy for film executives to miss the occasional understated plot point, which results in a ton of classic movies that are full of tragedy, even though they're marketed as family-friendly. 

Even if you're a certified film buff, there are still probably a few films you never realized are super sad. On the surface, these movies often appear pleasantly light-hearted, but a closer look proves that they're chock-full of murder, abuse, and mayhem. Sometimes the misery unfolds on-screen, but other films simply leave plot threads hanging that spell doom for their plucky protagonists. 

Hollywood movies sometimes get criticized for focusing too much on "happily ever afters," but in reality, they're pumping out all sorts of secretly depressing family movies

The Lion King is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list Beloved Family Classics That Are Chock-Full Of Tragedy
Photo:  The Lion King/Disney

While there's a lot of obviously dark stuff happening in The Lion King (a certain father being trampled to death springs to mind), in the end, the rightful king reclaims his throne and restores balance to the circle of life. The finale is set to some kickin' Elton John music, and it's absolutely uplifting. 

While it's not entirely clear how long Simba was gone, no other male lions appear to have been born during his absence. Scar is the only male lion in a sea of lady lions, and yet it doesn't appear that any new cubs were born. Was he practicing celibacy, or was he killing them before they became a threat? See, in real life, lions are known to routinely kill their young, so its highly possible that Scar eliminated all his future competition.  

Actors: Whoopi Goldberg, Jeremy Irons, Matthew Broderick, James Earl Jones, Rowan Atkinson, + more

Initial Release: 1994

Directed by: Rob Minkoff, Roger Allers

Also Ranked

#30 on The Most Rewatchable Movies

#1 on The Best Animated Films Ever

#10 on The Greatest Film Scores of All Time

#60 on The Greatest Epic Movies Ever Made

626 104
Is this movie unexpectedly sad?
see more on The Lion King
Shrek the Third is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list Beloved Family Classics That Are Chock-Full Of Tragedy
Photo:  Shrek/Dreamworks

In the Shrek films, the titular ogre departs from his isolated swamp and learns to accept himself and others for who they are. By the time the third film ends, he's gotten married, made a few close friends, and regularly pitches in to help his kingdom. 

That's all wonderful, but why was he in that swamp in the first place? Well, in Shrek the Third, we learn that his parents were horribly abusive. At one point, Shrek tells Artie that his dad tried to eat him, and that he's afraid of repeating the cycle of abuse with his own children. That's some heavy stuff for a movie with a talking donkey that loves waffles. 

Actors: Cameron Diaz, Justin Timberlake, Eddie Murphy, Amy Poehler, Julie Andrews, + more

Initial Release: 2007

Directed by: Chris Miller, Raman Hui

Also Ranked

#73 on The Best Halloween Movies for Kids

#56 on The Best CGI Animated Films Ever Made

#60 on The Best Third Films In A Movie Series

510 133
Is this movie unexpectedly sad?
see more on Shrek the Third
The Sound of Music is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list Beloved Family Classics That Are Chock-Full Of Tragedy
Photo:  The Sound Of Music/20th Century Fox

The Sound of Music is a timeless musical that showcases some of the best songs Richard Rodgers ever wrote. In the film, the Von Trapp family learns to love each other by accepting Maria Rainer (Julie Andrews) into their fold, then works together to escape the Nazi onslaught. 

While the majority of the film wraps up nicely, Rolf (Daniel Truhitte) — the lovable postman — ends up becoming a Nazi. After the credits roll, that cute boy who's seen dancing around a water fountain with Liesl (Charmian Carr) presumably goes on to kill and oppress Jewish people and Allied troops. If he survives the war, he'll surely be tried for crimes against humanity.

Actors: Julie Andrews, Christopher Plummer, Eleanor Parker, Nicholas Hammond, Heather Menzies, + more

Initial Release: 1965

Directed by: Robert Wise

Also Ranked

#32 on The Greatest Chick Flicks Ever Made

#18 on The Best Movies About Music

#50 on The Greatest Film Scores of All Time

#76 on The Greatest Epic Movies Ever Made

317 104
Is this movie unexpectedly sad?
see more on The Sound of Music
The Santa Clause is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list Beloved Family Classics That Are Chock-Full Of Tragedy
Photo:  The Santa Clause/Disney

In the first Santa Clause film, Scott Calvin (Tim Allen) learns that a person becomes Kris Kringle by killing the previous Santa and taking his clothes. None of Santa's tiny employees bat an eyelash when a new Father Christmas is crowned; they're perfectly comfortable never mentioning their former employer again. If that isn't depressing enough, the second film explains that in order to remain Santa Claus, Calvin needs to find a Mrs. Claus.

While this might not initially come off as dark, the rule implies that the previous Santa Claus must have also been married to a Mrs. Claus. After Calvin inadvertently causes Santa's untimely death, what in the world happens to that Santa's wife? Is she forced out of the workshop and made to wander the arctic tundra of the North Pole? Does she die too? Clearly, this entire series is structured around familial tragedy, and serves to document a centuries-old tradition of murdering Claus couples. 

Actors: Tim Allen, Frank Welker, Peter Boyle, David Krumholtz, Mary Gross, + more

Initial Release: 1994

Directed by: John Pasquin

Also Ranked

#10 on The Best Christmas Movies of All Time

#56 on The Best Movies for Tweens

#17 on The Best Disney Live-Action Movies

#30 on The Best Movies of 1994

284 107
Is this movie unexpectedly sad?
see more on The Santa Clause