Shay Mitchell Dating History: List Of All Her Boyfriends 

Updated October 24, 2019 16.2k views 5 items

Who is Shay Mitchell dating? Many famous men have dated Shay Mitchell, and this list will give you more details about these lucky dudes. Including Shay Mitchell’s current boyfriend, past relationships, pictures together, and dating rumors, this comprehensive dating history tells you everything you need to know about Shay Mitchell’s love life. In case you're also wondering, she's never married. 

This list features Shay Mitchell’s ex-boyfriends along with additional information about them, such as when they were born and what they do professionally. These men come in all shapes and sizes, but what they all have in common is that they're all men that Shay Mitchell has either dated or linked up with. It's not hard to get jealous of these men that Shay Mitchell has gone out with, so try your hardest to contain your envy.

According to rumors, Pretty Little Liars star Shay Mitchell is currently dating Matte Babel.

This list of Shay Mitchell’s boyfriends includes Jimmy Butler and Ryan Silverstein.

Check out the list of men Shay Mitchell has dated below.

Matte Babel

A post shared by mattebabel (@mattebabel) on

In 2017, Shay Mitchell is currently dating TV host and music reporter Matte Babel. 

The two announced they were expecting their first child together in June 2019, and shared a month later, via an unusual gender reveal, that they were expecting a girl. 

In October 2019, Mitchell revealed on Instagram that the pair had welcomed their daughter, posting a photo of her holding the infant's hand, along with the caption, "Never letting go..."

Age: 38

Birthplace: Toronto, Canada

Jimmy Butler is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list Shay Mitchell Dating History: List Of All Her Boyfriends
Photo:  Catherine Salaün/Wikimedia Commons

In May 2016, Shay Mitchell was spotted on a date with NBA player Jimmy Butler. 

Age: 29

Birthplace: Houston, Texas

More Jimmy Butler 

#91 of 873 The Top NBA Players Of All Time #27 of 320 The Top 100+ NBA Players Today #84 of 95 The Most Overrated Players In The NBA Today

Ryan Silverstein is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list Shay Mitchell Dating History: List Of All Her Boyfriends
Photo: Ryan Silverstein/Instagram
Ryan Silverstein

From 2013 to 2014, Shay Mitchell was in a relationship with Drake's assistant Ryan Silverstein. 

Age: 33

Birthplace: Toronto, Canada

Jacob Artist is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list Shay Mitchell Dating History: List Of All Her Boyfriends
Photo: Shay Mitchell/Instagram

In 2013, Shay Mitchell was rumored to be dating actor Jacob Artist. 

Age: 26

Birthplace: Buffalo, New York, United States of America