Graveyard Shift
1.1m readers

The 11 Strangest Twists in True Crime History

Updated March 1, 2021 1.1m views11 items

As if tales of murder aren't weird enough, there are some slayings that get stranger as time keeps passing. 

Weird twists don't just happen in the movies. Strange true crimes often take brutal turns out of nowhere: the crooked juror, the letters from serial killers discovered only years later, a memory of something a criminal said years ago that now is downright chilling. There are countless weird cases that got weirder as more evidence came to light. 

It goes to prove that no matter how much people think they have something figured out, there’s always something else waiting around the corner - be it a living victim everyone thought passed or a gruesome villain who was more evil than anyone realized. 

  • Photo: Sacramento Sheriff / Wikimedia Commons / Public Domain

    Over 40 Years After His Crime Spree, DNA Analysis Helped Catch The GSK

    In April 2018, the public was shocked when authorities announced they had apprehended a suspect in the Golden State Killer (GSK) case. The criminal terrorized California during the '70s and '80s in a spree of multiple rapes and 12 suspected fatalities, but he abruptly ended his reign of terror in the late '80s, leading to widespread speculation he died and his identity would never be revealed.

    The suspect, Joseph James DeAngelo, was identified via complex DNA profiling, though. Investigators compared DNA found at various GSK crime scenes to DNA publicly available via genealogical websites. This led them to a connection via a family member of DeAngelo. 

    What makes this twist even more bizarre was that DeAngelo was living a relatively normal life near Sacramento, California. Once a retired police officer, he was a regular at a local diner where his only notable trait was being grouchy. It remains unclear why he decided to end his crime spree and resume a normal life. 

  • Photo: Milwaukee Police Department / Wikipedia / Fair Use

    Sometimes it takes a long time before a twist is finally recognized, and in the case of Jeffrey Dahmer, it took many years for his neighbors to realize the personal impact of Dahmer's violence. Pamela Bass was one of Jeffrey Dahmer's neighbors when he lived in Milwaukee. The two were congenial, so much so that when he offered her a sandwich one day before his arrest, she accepted it. 

    After it was discovered that Dahmer was a cannibal as well as an amateur mad scientist, Bass began to worry that she might have eaten human meat. In the film The Jeffrey Dahmer Files she said, "I have probably eaten someone's body part." 

    More Jeffrey Dahmer 

    #32 of 130 Famous American Serial Killers#10 of 10 How 10 Notorious Criminals From History Actually Got Caught#3 of 61 The Scariest Serial Killers In History

  • Photo: Federal Bureau of Investigation / Wikimedia Commons / Public Domain

    Blood is thicker than water, unless your brother is the Unabomber. Ted Kaczynski, more commonly referred to as the Unabomber, wrote a manifesto that he wanted published by the biggest US media outlets in 1995. In it, he stated that if his demands were not met, he would continue his bombing campaign. 

    Unfortunately for Kaczynski, his life's work was also his life's undoing. His brother David read the manifesto, recognized his brother's handwriting and turned him into the federal authorities. To hear David tell it, he never planned on reading the manifesto, even after recognizing similarities between the bomber's theories and his brother's letters that were written while he was a professor at the University of California at Berkeley. 

    Despite Ted's arrest, David had trouble believing his brother was the Unabomber. "I had never seen him violent, not toward me, not toward anyone. I tended to see his anger turned inward."

    More Ted Kaczynski 

    #9 of 11 We Asked, You Answered: Which Serial Killer (Living Or Dead) Would You Want To Be Pen Pals With?#2 of 11 11 Terrifying Serial Killers with Extremely High IQs#5 of 44 The Heights Of The Most Notorious Killers

  • Photo: State of California, San Quentin Prison / Wikimedia Commons / Public Domain

    The story of Charles Manson, his life, and his "family" is full of more strange twists than an M. Night Shyamalan retrospective, but one of the weirdest twists is the mystery of Bernard Crowe. Before his infamous actions, Manson was in a dispute over drug money with Crowe. Worried about the money, and Crowe's affiliation with the Black Panthers, Manson went over to Crowe's apartment and shot him.

    Manson thought he took Crowe's life, and when he was arrested for the murders of Sharon Tate and the LaBiancas in 1969, he included Crowe as one of his victims. Except Crowe was alive. He had never gone to the police about the shooting, never told any of his fellow Black Panthers about it, and never retaliated against Manson, leaving the cult leader to believe Crowe was dead.

    Susan Atkins - a member of the Mason family - wrote in her book The Myth of Helter Skelter that Manson didn't realize Crowe was alive until he was arrested for a crime unrelated to Manson. 

    More Charles Manson 

    Rules Followers Had To Stick With To Stay In The Manson Family#1280 of 2,753 The Most Influential People of All Time#8 of 15 The Most Macabre Sights At The Dearly Departed Tours And Museum