Total Nerd

The Objectively Worst Decisions In ‘Stranger Things’ Season 3  

Jacob Shelton
July 11, 2019 2.1k votes 307 voters 4.1k views 14 items

List Rules Vote up the worst decisions in Season 3.

Stranger Things Season 3 is an exciting, nostalgia-inducing thrill ride, but its characters make some pretty dumb decisions. When you watch the season through for the first time, it’s hard to tell whether anyone is making a good decision or not. However, once you go over the character’s actions in your head, it’s hard to see the logic in their behavior. 

Every step along the way, the characters on Stranger Things make bad decisions, some of the worst in television history. Not everything they do is bad, but there are some seriously wrong turns that the citizens of Hawkins, Indiana, make whenever they’re faced with an important decision.

1 232 VOTES
Murray Leaving Alexei Alone At The Carnival
Murray Leaving Alexei Alone At... is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list The Objectively Worst Decisions In ‘Stranger Things’ Season 3
Photo: Netflix

Hours after realizing that Alexei works for a secret arm of the USSR that's intent on opening a portal to the Upside-Down, Murray leaves the runaway scientist alone at a carnival in the town where the secret arm of the USSR is based. 

It makes sense that Murray wanted Alexei to have some time to himself where he could take in all that small-town America had to offer, but they were still being chased by a Russian psychopath. 

Murray wouldn't have been able to fight off the Russian slayer, but he could have at least helped Alexei run or given him some kind of warning. Leaving Alexei alone causes a lot of problems for the Hawkins crew. 

Not only does it bring their team down one person, but it means that everything takes longer. Hopper, Joyce, and Murray can't get into the bunker immediately, and it takes longer to get into the control room. All of this ends with Hopper perishing in the finale's climactic moments. 

Was this a bad choice?
2 193 VOTES
The Misogynists At The Newspaper Ignoring Nancy
The Misogynists At The Newspap... is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list The Objectively Worst Decisions In ‘Stranger Things’ Season 3
Photo: Netflix

Did Nancy bring the editors at the paper a wild story about psycho rats in the basement of a schizophrenic woman? Sure. Did she have proof to back up her claim? Not really. Could they have investigated her story and tempered the effect of the Mind Flayer? 100 percent. 

By making fun of Nancy and being all-around horrible to her because she's a woman, her bosses prove themselves to be pure garbage. However, by ignoring, her the guys at the paper condemn the town of Hawkins to yet another disaster. 

Was this a bad choice?
3 208 VOTES
Mike Lying To Eleven About His Grandmother
Mike Lying To Eleven About His... is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list The Objectively Worst Decisions In ‘Stranger Things’ Season 3
Photo: Netflix

At the top of "The Mall Rats," Eleven calls Mike to ask why he's late, and rather than tell her that Hopper pressured him into staying away from her, or that they should take the day away from each other for some personal time, he tells her that his grandmother is sick. 

This lie sets off a chain reaction that Mike only recovers from after half the town is mind-flayed. His mom thinks her mom is sick, El is so mad, and Mike and El's relationship is damaged for the majority of the season. 

Was this a bad choice?
4 180 VOTES
Billy Secretly Meeting With Mrs. Wheeler
Billy Secretly Meeting With Mr... is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list The Objectively Worst Decisions In ‘Stranger Things’ Season 3
Photo: Netflix

There are a lot of problems with the teenage Billy setting up a late-night tryst with Mike's mom at a motel, but the biggest ramifications come from Billy helping the Mind Flayer come into the real world. 

On his way to the clandestine hookup, something hits Billy's windshield and he wrecks near the old mill. It just so happens that the Mind Flayer lives in the old mill, and it shoves Billy into the Upside-Down before taking over his body. 

If Billy had just been respectful of Karen's emotions, then Hawkins wouldn't have had to worry about the Mind Flayer and instead they could have focused on the imminent threat posed by the Russians. 

Was this a bad choice?