Button Mash

10 Video Games That Are The Black Sheep Of Their Franchise  

Mark Austin
791 votes 245 voters 11.7k views 10 items

List Rules Vote up the most unexpectedly weird video game franchise entries.

Great games can spawn great or lousy sequels but, sometimes, we get strange video game sequels. Of course, the safest sequel is a basically a carbon copy of the original. On the other hand, later iterations or “reboots” of beloved video games can veer off the beaten path in unexpected directions. You've got games that switch genres, styles, objectives - the games on this list prove that sometimes, everything you think you know about a franchise can be thrown out the window at a moment's notice. These sequels to great video games embraced the weirdness, in more ways than one - some succeeded, some crashed and burned. 

Pokémon Snap is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list 10 Video Games That Are The Black Sheep Of Their Franchise
Photo: Nintendo

The Pokémon franchise made the jump from GameBoy to N64 with 1999's Pokémon Snap, a relaxing 3D first-person rail photography sim, based on a top-down turn-based RPG about capturing and training cute animals to fight in pits of death. Not a whole lot of overlap in those Venn diagrams, one might say.

In the game, you travel around in a little golf cart and take photos of Pokémon. Then you do it again. And again. There are no battles, no capturing, no leveling up. It’s rather Zen and quite relaxing in its serenity, actually. You really have to think about and plan the composition of your photos. You're an artist, dammit! Plus, it’s always fun to use a Pester Ball to annoy the local wildlife.

Release: 1999

Developer: HAL Laboratory, Pax Softnica

Platform: Nintendo 64, Wii

More Pokémon Snap

#7 of 14 on 14 Video Games That Totally Deserve A Rerelease Or Remake #24 of 68 on The Best Pokémon Video Games, Ranked #3 of 9 on Forgotten Video Game Sub-Franchises That Need To Make A Comeback #1 of 13 on The Best Pokémon Console Games, Ranked

see more on Pokémon Snap
Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's I... is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list 10 Video Games That Are The Black Sheep Of Their Franchise
Photo: Nintendo

For some reason, Nintendo was in no hurry to capitalize on the huge success of their 1990 flagship game for the Super NES. The first Super Mario World was a typical Shigeru Miyamoto tour-de-force, a blockbuster that redefined platform gaming and introduced conventions that are still widely used today. Any other company would have had SMW2 out a year later, but Nintendo always follows their own drumbeat.

Almost six years later - near the twilight of the Super NES life cycle - Yoshi’s Island comes out, a cartoonish, goofy riff on platforming the likes of which had never been seen before.

The hand-drawn aesthetic is not unusual nowadays, but it was revolutionary and eye-catching back then. Supposedly, Miyamoto chose the exaggerated crayon-drawn animation style as a rebuke to the computer-rendered sprite graphics from games like Donkey Kong Country that were prevalent at the time.

It was an awesome game, but not every entertainment powerhouse would sign off on depicting their beloved corporate mascot as a diaper-clad mewling infant clinging to the back of a homicidal dinosaur that poops out weird eggs.

Release: 1995

Developer: Nintendo, Nintendo Entertainment Analysis & Development

Platform: Super Nintendo Entertainment System, Sega Mega Drive, Game Boy Advance

More Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island

#13 of 178 on The Best Super Nintendo (SNES) Games #57 of 148 on The Greatest Classic Video Game Theme Songs Ever #66 of 419 on The Best Video Game Soundtracks of All Time #38 of 209 on The Best Nintendo Games, Ranked

see more on Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island
Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts & Bolts is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list 10 Video Games That Are The Black Sheep Of Their Franchise
Photo: Rare

You’d think after the runaway success of the first two Banjo-Kazooie games, Rare would have this formula down pat. Another globe-trotting adventure for the wisecracking duo? More co-op platforming, more gorgeous expansive environments, more insane collectible quests?

Hmm, not quite. Hey, kids! Let’s all get jobs at the junkyard! Nuts & Bolts (2008) for Xbox 360 was all about… building vehicles out of scraps.

To defeat the evil witch this time, you have to construct cars, boats, motorcycles, and planes to complete stunt challenges. While there's some platforming involved, most of the time, you’re designing blueprints for new vehicles in your lab or piloting them around various courses.

Having a virtual erector set and making your own wacky contraptions was certainly a blast, but it’s a jarring departure from the wide-ranging journeys of a bird and a bear from the previous two installments.

Release: Nov 11 2008

Developer: Ashby Computers and Graphics Ltd., Rare Ltd

More Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts & Bolts

#76 of 200 on The Best Games On Xbox Game Pass #59 of 66 on The Best Games For Kids on Xbox Games Pass #28 of 55 on The Best Adventure Games on Xbox Game Pass #34 of 74 on The Best Rare Games List

see more on Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts & Bolts
Star Fox Adventures is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list 10 Video Games That Are The Black Sheep Of Their Franchise
Photo: Nintendo

Star Fox (1993) showcased Nintendo’s shiny new Super FX chip, which delivered some revolutionary 3D graphics to a home console. Fox McCloud was a gruff furry who zoomed through the galaxy in his cool spaceship blasting evil aliens with a whole squadron of fighters. Star Fox 64 (1997) delivered much of the same fun plot and innovative graphics. So what did Nintendo do for a sequel?

Five years later, Star Fox Adventures (2002) was released for the GameCube. Again, it featured Fox, but he was missing his coolest accessory - his spaceship! Instead, he was running around on a primitive world alone, killing enemies with a stick or something.

The game was originally developed by Rare as Dinosaur Planet, and it was essentially a Zelda clone. While a fun game in its own right, Star Fox Adventures was like tossing Captain Kirk down to the Gorn planet for a full season.

Release: 2002

Developer: Ashby Computers and Graphics Ltd., Rare Ltd

Platform: GameCube, Super Nintendo Entertainment System

More Star Fox Adventures

#20 of 20 on The Easiest Video Games To Complete #37 of 103 on The Best Super Nintendo Adventure Games #8 of 100 on The Best GameCube Adventure Games

see more on Star Fox Adventures