Button Mash

The Most Elaborate and Weirdly Plausible Super Mario Fan Theories

List Rules
Vote up the most entertaining fan theories from any installment of Super Mario Bros.

Super Mario fans certainly get points for creativity. They've followed Mario in video game form, films, and cartoons, so it's no surprise that they've come up with some fascinating conspiracy theories about their favorite Italian superhero over the years. Here are just a few of the amazing Super Mario fan theories out there, to fuel speculation and discuss among your gamer friends.