Total Nerd
783 voters

Super Mario Odyssey Fan Theories

Updated January 29, 2018 3.5k votes 783 voters 27.0k views10 items

List RulesVote up the Super Mario Odyssey fan theories that make you say mamma mia!

Since it hit platforms on October 27, 2017, a shocking number of Super Mario Odyssey fan theories have been pouring in from all corners of the internet. Even more shocking is how creepy most of these theories are. From Mario being trapped in a simulation to the Italian plumber actually being a stalker, things get pretty dark in the Mushroom Kingdom when the story is left to the fans to ponder. These games are fodder for some pretty messed up fantasies.

Some Super Mario Odyssey fan theories do explore parts of the Mario universe that don't make all that much sense - things like the fact that Peach never hires any extra security after being kidnapped 876897698 times or the fact that there doesn't seem to be any actual continuity between the games. These fan theories are humanity's attempt to make sense of that which eludes us, just like Bowser seems to elude Mario time after time.

  • 1

    New Donk City Is Mario's Hometown

    Photo: Nintendo

    New Donk City is one of the highlights of Super Mario Odyssey, and not just because it celebrates more than three decades of Mario history with its musical and visual homages to the earlier installments in the series. According to a Reddit fan theory, the reason the city is so nostalgic for Mario's previous adventures - especially Donkey Kong - is that this is actually the Italian plumber's hometown. 

    Why does Mario look so different to the other suit-wearing citizens of New Donk City? The answer is simple: after years of hanging out in the Mushroom Kingdom and "consuming magic mushrooms," Mario's body has mutated to look more "cartoony" like the other citizens of the kingdom. If that's not science, what is?

    Does this make sense?
  • 2

    Mario's Cappy Abilities Are Actually Demonic

    Photo: Nintendo

    Twitter is a little worried about Mario's ability to control anything or anyone he wants with a magical red cap. In fact, some fans theorize that this ability is actually demonic, which raises many ethical questions about Mario. Should he be able to control people and creatures against their will? And can the possessed remember what they did while under Mario's control? It gets pretty creepy when you think about it...

    Does this make sense?
  • 3

    Peach Actually Left Mario For Bowser

    Photo: Nintendo

    Okay, Super Mario is about to jump into Braid territory. What if Peach has actually left Mario for Bowser countless times and the Italian plumber has become a stalker determined to get her back? According to this Reddit theory, the only time Bowser actually kidnapped Peach was in the original Super Mario Bros. 

    Peach decided to be with Mario after he rescued her, but things didn't work out between the two, which is why she decided to hang with Bowser again. This drove Mario crazy, making him believe that the only reason Peach would leave him for Bowser is that the "villain" kidnapped her again.

    In Super Mario Odyssey, Bowser hasn't kidnapped Peach to get married. They actually mean to marry, but then Mario crashes the party. Of course, this is all assuming Peach has been in a relationship with either of them at all. 


    Does this make sense?
  • 4

    Mario Has Been Dead The Whole Time

    Photo: Nintendo

    Here's a spooky theory: Mario has been dead throughout the events of Super Mario Odyssey. It's not hard to believe that the game is Mario's death fantasy, considering just how weird the premise is from the very beginning. After being ambushed by Bowser on an airship, Mario seemingly falls to his death, only to find himself on a strange black and white (hairy?) world populated by ghosts wearing hats (essentially what Cappy is), which give the hero's new surroundings a distinctly supernatural feel. 

    From there, Mario's adventure truly begins, as he explores many strange worlds, including many nostalgic ones that look back at his past adventures. Might this be Mario's life flashing before his eyes? This would certainly explain why New Donk City is reminiscent of his first adventure in Donkey Kong...

    Does this make sense?