VOTE

The 19 Hottest Girls Who've Turned Down Playboy  

Greg Stopera
126.4k votes 18.2k voters 7.7M views 19 items

List Rules Hot Women You Won't Believe Said No to Playboy

Prepare to gather up your magazines, curl up in a ball, and weep openly. These hot women have shown plenty of skin on camera, teased the hell out of you but have refused to bare it all, even for millions of dollars. From reigning babe Jessica Alba to Britney Spears in her hay day to even people everyone's seen naked like Paris Hilton, here are the 20 hottest women who've turned down Playboy, yet continue to turn you on.

For more sexy ladies, check out these lists of the hottest British women and hottest French ladies.

Have you searched for Jennifer Aniston Playboy, Jessica Alba Playboy, Katy Perry Playboy, or Stacy Keibler Playboy only to be disappointed? Well you're not alone.

These hot women all said "no" to Playboy, much to the chagrin of the known universe.

back to page 1
Jennifer Love Hewitt is listed (or ranked) 5 on the list The 19 Hottest Girls Who've Turned Down Playboy
Photo: via Reddit

Looking fine on a bed has pretty much cut it for Jennifer Love Hewwitt for the last decade or so, but she's absolutely refused to do much more nudity than she did in that tanning scene in I Still Know What You Did Last Summer.

Although reportedly flattered, she said no when they asked her to take it all off because she still looks absolutely amazing. I mean, there's that George Lopez video from just this last year of her talking about how she VaJazzles herself (that is vagina bedazzling, for all you guys not around for the first part of 2010.)

Age: 40

Birthplace: Waco, Texas, United States of America

More Jennifer Love Hewitt

#70 of 665 on The Most Beautiful Women Of 2019, Ranked #27 of 32 on 32 Celebrities Who Have Insane Phobias #29 of 227 on The Greatest Former Child Stars #88 of 504 on The Best TV Actors of All Time

Do you wish she posed for Playboy?
see more on Jennifer Love Hewitt
Cheryl Cole is listed (or ranked) 6 on the list The 19 Hottest Girls Who've Turned Down Playboy
Photo:  Wikimedia Commons (CC-BY)

Cheryl Cole is a British singer who's part of a British p***ycat Dolls type band called Girls Aloud (see what they did there?). She's currently also a judge on the "American Idol" style show (they do "their own thing" in other countries, it seems) "The X Factor." Unlike Paula Abdul, you can actually look at Cheryl Cole, though, and it doesn't burn.

So no idea why this person never did Playboy. Maybe she's just waiting for that last minute to finally cash in, kind of like in an eBay auction, but who knows. Also, she probably would've been in the British Playboy, which means we'd get a few measly pages here and there or have to pay double for what is essentially the same magazine only talking about stuff we don't give a crap about.

Age: 35

Birthplace: Newcastle upon Tyne, United Kingdom

More Cheryl Cole

#97 of 225 on The Best Current Female Singers #25 of 88 on The Best Reality Show Judges #61 of 66 on The Greatest Dancing Singers featuring All Of Cheryl Cole's Famous Boyfriends, From Liam Payne To Derek Hough

Do you wish she posed for Playboy?
see more on Cheryl Cole
Sarah Michelle Gellar is listed (or ranked) 7 on the list The 19 Hottest Girls Who've Turned Down Playboy
Photo:  Wikimedia Commons (CC-BY)

During her "Buffy" days, Sarah Michelle Gellar was one of the hot ones, and one of the most coveted geek women ever (who wasn't actually a geek.)

Joss Whedon (creator of "Buffy the Vampire Slayer") wouldn't have a problem with sexing Buffy up a little, and actually had a few whole seasons where Buffy had all kinds of sex (and now an entire climax in the comic books about Buffy having sex, no pun intended.)

So it wasn't that she was leaning on her studio/PR manager/agent saying no, it's just that she was that conservative. And after seven seasons of a successful television show that still has one of the most rabid and loyal followings in the history of entertainment, you can do that.

So, she can parade around in bras, wear only black lingerie, hang around in highly questionable business attire and participate in one of the hottest lesbian kisses in the history of film, but she can't do Playboy.

Even though she's a complete sweetheart, that, is weird. Luckily, she's aged like wine and if that "Buffy" reboot ever goes through she'll be relevant enough to warrant a spread. Here's hoping!

Age: 41

Birthplace: New York City, New York, United States of America

More Sarah Michelle Gellar

#71 of 277 on The Most Trustworthy Celebrities in the World #25 of 32 on 32 Celebrities Who Have Insane Phobias #31 of 227 on The Greatest Former Child Stars featuring The Celebrity Loves Of Sarah Michelle Gellar's Life

Do you wish she posed for Playboy?
see more on Sarah Michelle Gellar
Britney Spears is listed (or ranked) 8 on the list The 19 Hottest Girls Who've Turned Down Playboy
Photo: via Twitter

I know. I need to explain why this is so high up. Nowadays she does things like this:

Paris Hilton, Britney Spears and Lindsay Lohan in a car together. All in one place.

That's when you know you're in trouble.

Age: 37

Birthplace: McComb, Mississippi, United States of America

More Britney Spears

#22 of 233 on The Greatest New Female Vocalists of the Past 10 Years #29 of 225 on The Best Current Female Singers featuring The Best Britney Spears Music Videos The Best Britney Spears Songs of All Time

Do you wish she posed for Playboy?
see more on Britney Spears