The Best New TV Mysteries of the Last Few Years

Updated September 29, 2023 16.8K votes 3.2K voters 141.7K views

Over 3.2K Ranker voters have come together to rank this list of The Best New TV Mysteries of the Last Few Years

Voting Rules

Vote up the best scripted mystery series that premiered their first season on or after January 1, 2019.

Latest additions: The Vanishing Triangle, Wilderness, The Other Black Girl

Most divisive: The Society

With so many great TV series currently airing, we’re ranking the best mystery TV shows since 2019. Our list of the highest-rated TV mysteries of the past few years is ranked by viewers from everywhere, so make sure you vote up the best new mystery series on television. What is the best new mystery TV show?

Featuring new Netflix mystery shows, Hulu originals, critically acclaimed miniseries, and more, the best recent mystery shows include Home Before Dark, Pretty Little Liars: The Perfectionists, and Cruel Summer. The Netflix series Lupin is considered to be one of the most binge-worthy shows today, while Applet TV+'s Servant and HBO Max's The Flight Attendant are known as the shows to watch now.

What are television's best recent mystery shows? Vote up the TV mysteries you think are the best to have premiered recently and see where your favorites rank.

Ranked by

1
Ridley
Adrian Dunbar, Bronagh Waugh, Terence Maynard
6 votes
- Premiered: August 28, 2022
Retired Detective Inspector Alex Ridley consults on a missing person case which takes a dark turn.
- #124 of 173
  The Best Shows Currently On The Air
- #92 of 103
  The Best British Detective Series
- #74 of 112
  The Very Best British Crime Dramas
Available On:
subscription
$1.99 $1.99
2
Midnight Mass
Zach Gilford, Kate Siegel, Hamish Linklater
166 votes
- Premiered: September 24, 2021
Midnight Mass, a horror-drama series, expertly weaves together elements of mystery and the supernatural to create an engaging viewing experience. With a talented ensemble cast led by Hamish Linklater (Father Paul), the show delves into the lives of a small island community as they navigate a series of unsettling occurrences. The series has garnered critical acclaim for its exceptional storytelling, character development, and atmospheric setting. Midnight Mass expertly balances its chilling narrative with poignant explorations of faith and redemption, making it a compelling watch.
Available On:
subscription
3
Squid Game
Lee Jung-jae, Park Hae-soo, Oh Yeong-su
203 votes
- Premiered: September 17, 2021
In the realm of television, there occasionally emerges a show that transcends borders and becomes a global phenomenon. Squid Game is a prime example of this, with its gripping narrative centered around a deadly competition that unfolds within a dystopian society. The South Korean thriller, directed by Hwang Dong-hyuk, has captivated audiences worldwide, earning critical acclaim and several award nominations. Through its intricate storytelling and compelling character development, particularly that of Seong Gi-hun (Lee Jung-jae) and Cho Sang-woo (Park Hae-soo), Squid Game delves into themes of morality, social inequality, and survival, all while maintaining an air of suspense that keeps viewers on the edge of their seats.
- The Best Characters On Netflix's 'Squid Game'
- #26 of 556
  The Best New Netflix Originals Of The Last Few Years
- #115 of 2,385
  The Greatest TV Shows Of All Time
Available On:
subscription
4
Wednesday
Jenna Ortega, Catherine Zeta-Jones, Riki Lindhome
134 votes
- Premiered: November 23, 2022
Wednesday Addams tries to master her psychic ability while attending Nevermore Academy.
Available On:
subscription
5
Cruel Summer
Sadie Stanley, Lexi Underwood, Griffin Gluck
128 votes
- Premiered: April 20, 2021
Cruel Summer, a thrilling drama series, unravels the enigmatic tale of two young women whose lives become inextricably intertwined over three fateful years. The story is masterfully told through shifting perspectives, revealing secrets and unexpected twists with each episode. Anchored by stellar performances from Olivia Holt (Kate Wallis) and Chiara Aurelia (Jeanette Turner), the show delves into the complex dynamics of friendship, family, and the search for truth. As the plot thickens, viewers are drawn deeper into a web of deception, leaving them questioning who is truly innocent or guilty. Garnering critical acclaim and a fervent fanbase, Cruel Summer has solidified its place as a must-watch psychological thriller.
Available On:
subscription
free
$1.99 $1.99
6
London Kills
Hugo Speer, Sharon Small, Bailey Patrick
30 votes
- Premiered: February 25, 2019
Following the detectives of an elite murder investigation squad in London.
- #85 of 251
  The Best BBC One Shows
- #415 of 542
  The 500+ Best Drama Shows
- #40 of 69
  The Best Original Series On Acorn TV
Available On:
subscription
$1.99 $1.99 $1.99

Ridley

Available On:

Midnight Mass

Available On:

Squid Game

Available On:

Wednesday

Available On:

Cruel Summer

Available On:

London Kills

Available On: