753 voters

The Best Peanut Butter Candy

Updated February 6, 2019 4.2k votes 753 voters 9.8k views13 items

List RulesSweet food that contains peanut butter as an ingredient.

This list of the best peanut butter candy includes only the greatest candy with peanut butter in it. Anyone with a sweet tooth who also doesn't have a peanut allergy has a favorite peanut butter candy. So, what is the top peanut butter candy? Whether you prefer it in cups, bars, balls, or pieces - you’ll find your favorite in this list. 

While this list is about determining once and for all which peanut butter candy is the best, it’s important to remember that pretty much all candy with peanut butter in it is pretty great. After all, it’s candy... with peanut butter in it! How can you mess that up? Chocolate is good, but it tastes way better when it’s mixed with peanut butter. The same goes with taffy. If it tastes like PB, it’s A-OK. 

Reese’s may have the most varieties of great peanut butter candy, but is Reese’s the best peanut butter candy? E.T. loved Reese’s Pieces, but do you also think they’re out of this world? There may be no wrong way to eat a Reese’s, but would you want to chew on a classic peanut butter candy like Mary Jane instead? Maybe you're from Ohio and, in defiance, would refuse a store bought treat in preference of a homemade batch of Buckeyes.

With so many varieties of peanut butter candy, it can be hard to decide which is the best overall peanut butter treat, but the time has come to decide. Vote up your favorite peanut butter candies below!