Total Nerd

The Greatest Fan Theories About The Simpsons 

Lisa Waugh
Updated June 14, 2019 94.5k votes 17k voters 937k views 20 items

With a show spanning two decades, there’s been plenty of time to dissect the characters and storylines to come up with all manner of The Simpsons fan theories. Despite being an animation show, The Simpsons is still one of the best current sitcoms out there and its popularity has resulted in many fan theories. For instance, some fans believe The Simpsons are geniuses and choose to be dullards (except for Lisa) because it’s more fun. Others think that the show is a show within The Simpsons universe. There are also a lot of The Simpsons theories about where Springfield actually is; is it in another dimension or the Southern Hemisphere or Northern Kentucky?
The Simpsons conspiracy theories run the gamut, explaining the trap doors of character behavior and the running inconsistencies in the plot. Like why Hans Moleman dies, but shows up for more episodes. This The Simpsons theory suggests that it’s because he’s part of a legion of hybrid molemen who live underground and they are thwarted in their attempts to take over Springfield, mainly because of Homer. And that Grandpa Abe’s time traveling interferes with history and causes plot holes.
There are other popular fan theories about The Simpsons such as that Moe has known all along that Bart is the prank caller. Or that Homer has been in a coma for since the beginning and that’s why the characters never age. There’s a bizarre fan theory that the Simpsons are yellow because of Duff beer. What’s your favorite The Simpsons fan theory? Vote it up to the top of the list.

Bart Will Grow Up to Create the Simpsons
Bart Will Grow Up to Cre... is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list The Greatest Fan Theories About The Simpsons
Photo: Fox
Matt Groening based the show on his own family, down to the names of his parents and sisters. It would make a lot of sense that Bart, the kid dead set on shenanigans, ends up following his love for comedy and creating a show based on his family.
Is this plausible?
Homer Has Been in a Coma for Over Two Decades
Homer Has Been in a Coma... is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list The Greatest Fan Theories About The Simpsons
Photo: Fox
Hardtopickaname put this theory together from a 1992 episode in which Homer is talking to God.
Homer: God, I gotta ask you something. What's the meaning of life?
God: Homer, I can't tell you that.
Homer: C'mon!
God: You'll find out when you die.
Homer: I can't wait that long!
God: You can't wait six months?
Homer: No, tell me now!
God: Well, ok. The meaning of life is…
Then six months later, there’s a scene where Bart pulls a prank that puts Homer in a coma. He’s been in that coma ever since. That’s why no one ages. They are captured in Homer’s mind from the last time he saw them, but he’s been entertaining the world with those memories. 
BTW, this theory has been shared around the world. Hardtopickaname posted this update on Reddit: This got really big. I'm getting messages about it making the news in Australia, Belgium, and other places. It made the front page of Yahoo, and TMZ even got a statement from Al Jean about my theory. He says it's not true, but what does he know about the Simpsons?”
Is this plausible?
Bart Is as Smart as Lisa - Maybe Smarter
Bart Is as Smart as Lisa... is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list The Greatest Fan Theories About The Simpsons
Photo: Fox
If you follow certain storylines, Bart ends up being a Chief Justice or the creator of The Simpsons, so the theory goes that Bart earlier in life prefers the prank life over being a teacher’s pet like Lisa. Later on, he’ll embrace his intelligence and make a big splash in the world.
Is this plausible?
Every Simpson Is a Super Genius
Every Simpson Is a Super... is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list The Greatest Fan Theories About The Simpsons
Photo: Fox

This theory holds that all of The Simpsons are incredibly gifted, but only Lisa capitalizes on it. The reason? Ignorance is bliss. Grandpa did many amazing things until he got old and forgetful. Homer was intelligent until he got a crayon lodged in his brain; he even put it back after turning back into a super genius when he felt alienated from his regular friends.

Bart has chosen to hide his smarts, and prefers a life of smartassery. Maggie has pulled off some amazing feats for a baby. Marge likes the simpler life, and knows that being a brainiac makes you miserable. Just look at Lisa.

Is this plausible?