Total Nerd

The Existentially Bleak Observations About 14 Classic Cartoons  

Ashley Reign
545 votes 99 voters 3.4k views 14 items

List Rules Vote up the bleakest realities in these classic cartoons.

In search of some childhood-crushing reality? Here you'll have the chance to learn the horrible, disheartening truths and fan theories about some of your favorite classic cartoons. Some of these realities are pretty far-fetched, while others present an alarming amount of evidence to back up their claims. Many of them may not be for the faint of heart and should certainly not be passed along to anyone still in the throes of childhood wonder. 

If you're still bold enough to continue, prepare for a perspective on your favorite childhood cartoons that you may never be able to unsee. Which ones are so outlandish that they might actually hold water? Vote up the dark cartoon realities that are the most unnerving and grim.

Charlie Brown is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list The Existentially Bleak Observations About 14 Classic Cartoons
Photo: It's the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown/Warner Bros.

Charlie Brown, the lead character of Charles Schultz's famous Peanuts comic strip, is frequently downtrodden and miserable. He was even highlighted in Psychology Today for being "a model neurotic." Charlie seems to suffer from frequent bad luck, as well as many depressive episodes. He mostly spends his childhood overanalyzing the joy out of his own life.  

When he needs help, he turns to Lucy, arguably the most manipulative girl in town who can't even be trusted to hold a football in place, let alone tackle the obstacles of mental health. Despite the occasional joy Charlie manages to squeeze out of conversations with his dog Snoopy, his life seems destined to continue on a downward spiral.

More Charlie Brown

#21 of 343 on The Greatest Cartoon Characters in TV History #3 of 14 on Cartoon Characters You Never Realized Suffer From Mental Disorders #3 of 17 on Popular Male Cartoon Characters Voiced By Women #5 of 30 on The Best Yellow Characters

Is this bleak?
see more on Charlie Brown
2 53 VOTES
Rudolph The Red-Nosed Reindeer's Bullies Only Embrace Him Because His Physical Deformity Is Useful
Rudolph The Red-Nosed Reindeer... is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list The Existentially Bleak Observations About 14 Classic Cartoons
Photo: Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer/NBC Universal

Despite being beloved for generations, Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer contains some pretty horrible lessons for children. The titular reindeer happens to have an incredibly luminescent nose, a physical quirk which none of the other reindeer respect. Rather than treating him as their equal, they mock poor Rudolph relentlessly.

Rather than standing up for himself or becoming an otherwise useful member of society, Rudolph simply leaves town. Only later, when his deformity is recognized as a strength that the other reindeer can utilize, is Rudolph embraced by his society. The other reindeer never apologize for their behavior, nor do they attempt to befriend Rudolph in any meaningful way. The lesson appears to be "oppress those who are different, unless their differences prove profitable."

Is this bleak?
Peter Pan is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list The Existentially Bleak Observations About 14 Classic Cartoons
Photo: via Wikimedia Commons

Some fans of Disney's 1953 film, Peter Pan, suggest its titular character's motives for whisking children off to Neverland are surprisingly dismal. In theory, children who travel to Neverland neither leave nor grow up, a condition which the original book suggested Peter takes very seriously. The book reveals that if members of the Lost Boys do grow up, Peter routinely "thins them out." What exactly this entails is left to the reader's own imagination. 

An alternate but equally disheartening theory claims that Peter is actually the Grim Reaper, and that the children in the story have already perished when he visits their home. He arrives to transport them to a magical land where they will never grow old but will never be able to return to their former lives.

More Peter Pan

#15 of 78 on The Best Once Upon a Time Characters #24 of 198 on The Greatest Immortal Characters in Fiction #33 of 43 on The Best Green Characters #2 of 103 on Fictional Characters Named Peter

Is this bleak?
see more on Peter Pan
Tigger is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list The Existentially Bleak Observations About 14 Classic Cartoons
Photo: The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh/Disney-ABC Television

Despite Tigger's happy and peppy attitude, his iconic stripes may mask a tragic past. Even in his own theme song, Tigger admits that despite all the glories of Tiggers, he's the only one. None of his friends in the Hundred Acre Wood ever broach the delicate subject of what exactly happened to his kin.

Some fans suggest a tragic famine took all the other Tiggers out, or perhaps they all left the Hundred Acre Wood in a mass exodus, inexplicably leaving Tigger behind. Regardless, although Tigger seems reasonably well-adjusted, it's safe to assume that there must be some less-than-happy explanation for the absence of other Tiggers. 

Even The Tigger Movie, a 2000 animated film specifically focused on Tigger's search for his mysterious family, fails to provide an answer to the grim question.

More Tigger

#8 of 343 on The Greatest Cartoon Characters in TV History #24 of 200 on The Greatest Fictional Pets You Wish You Could Actually Own #13 of 134 on The Greatest Talking Animals in TV History #1 of 14 on Cartoon Characters You Never Realized Suffer From Mental Disorders

Is this bleak?
see more on Tigger