Total Nerd Serious Harry Potter Fans Completely Freak Out Over These Parts Of The Movies  

Stephan Roget
872 votes 158 voters 5.7k views 14 items Embed

List Rules Vote up the discrepancies between the books and movies that most make you want to send a howler to Warner Bros.

The list of things book readers hate about the Harry Potter movies is as long as the list of school supplies for a first-year student at Hogwarts. Although the films were generally well-received, the Harry Potter books inspired an intense fandom, and that’s ensured a certain amount of snobbery when it comes to changes made in the course of adaptation. What Harry Potter purists hate the most about the movies are the innumerable small changes, omissions, and embellishments that seem completely unnecessary to those who feel the original versions are perfect.

There doesn’t seem to be any particular film that draws more ire from Harry Potter purists, with all the movies in the series earning their fair share of criticism. Instead, fans seem to take umbrage (no pun intended) with the consistent differences that writers, directors, and actors chose to make for the sake of adaptation. To a dedicated book reader, these changes stand out like a troll in the dungeon.

1 64 VOTES

The Omission Of Voldemort’s Past


The Omission Of Voldemort’s Pa... is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list Serious Harry Potter Fans Completely Freak Out Over These Parts Of The Movies
Photo:  Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire/Warner Brothers

Although the Harry Potter books focus mainly on the story of their titular hero, the origin of Voldemort, who was once Tom Riddle, is also given plenty of attention. Book Six is devoted in great part to Harry and Dumbledore's journey through Riddle's past via memories. In the books, Harry finds out about the personal history of not just Voldemort, but his immediate family members, too. Reddit user morsmodre92 feels that the omission of all this additional info about Voldemort's past reduces him from how truly well-rounded as an evil villain he is in the books. The films make him less complex antagonist and more standard movie bad guy.

60 4
Agree or disagree?
2 59 VOTES

The Omission Of The Marauders’ Backstory


The Omission Of The Marauders’... is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list Serious Harry Potter Fans Completely Freak Out Over These Parts Of The Movies
Photo:  Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban/Warner Brothers

Obviously, films don’t have as much time to play around with fun side stories as novels. Adaptations often have to cut a lot of background information and subplot from their storylines. This has happened quite a bit in the Harry Potter series, but Reddit user chaimahannachi thinks that the lack of a true backstory for the Marauders was the most glaring omission. The group, made up of James Potter, Remus Lupin, Sirius Black, and Peter Pettigrew, are the creators of the Marauder’s Map. Their friendship plays a very important role in the overall story of not only The Prisoner of Azkaban, but the entire series. Unfortunately, fans who only watched the film missed out on much of this personal history.

55 4
Agree or disagree?
3 85 VOTES

Ginny Weasley’s Lack Of Personality


Ginny Weasley’s Lack Of Person... is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list Serious Harry Potter Fans Completely Freak Out Over These Parts Of The Movies
Photo:  Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince/Warner Brothers

In the books, readers watch Ginny Weasley develop into a strong, smart, and sassy young woman who was every bit Harry’s equal and the perfect romantic interest for him. According to many book fans, including Reddit user potatochops, those qualities don’t show up in the film adaptation of Ginny. Movie Ginny’s personality is seriously lacking, making it a bit of a mystery why Harry falls for her in the first place. The adapted version of Ginny lacks a lot of the agency and independence that the book version displayed.

75 10
Agree or disagree?
4 73 VOTES

Harry Not Repairing His Own Wand When He Has The Elder Wand


Harry Not Repairing His Own Wa... is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list Serious Harry Potter Fans Completely Freak Out Over These Parts Of The Movies
Photo:  Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part II/Warner Brothers

A meaningful moment in the Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows involves Harry using the Elder Wand to repair his broken original wand. It shows that Harry hasn’t lost touch with who he is, despite the events he’s been through. One Redditer complains that the final film skipped this moment entirely, instead depicting Harry as breaking the Elder Wand in two without so much as a second thought. The movie never explains what ended up happening with Harry’s original wand.

65 8
Agree or disagree?