Entertainment

Netflix Shows And Movies That Are Based On Real Crimes  

Jodi Smith
3.7k votes 1k voters 107.4k views 25 items

List Rules Vote up the Netflix shows that are most worth binging.

Truth is usually stranger than fiction, which explains why there are so many Netflix shows based on real crimes. The streaming giant has enough crime documentaries, movies, and in-depth television series based on actual crimes that you could watch for days and never see the same murder twice. These Netflix true crime shows and movies are utterly captivating - perfect for an afternoon binge-watch. And if you like these programs, be sure to check out our list of the best crime movies on Netflix and the true story that inspired Netflix's Unbelievable.

Mindhunter is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list Netflix Shows And Movies That Are Based On Real Crimes
Photo:  Mindhunter/Netflix

Mindhunter follows the fictitious FBI agents Holden Ford and Bill Tench as they interview infamous serial killers and collaborate with Dr. Wendy Carr to usher in a new way of investigating crime.

Ford is based on John E. Douglas, an FBI agent and author who interviewed killers featured on the show, such as Richard Speck and Edmund Kemper. Tench is based on Robert K. Ressler, an FBI agent who reportedly coined the term "serial killer." Carr is based on Dr. Ann Wolbert Burgess, who published a study of serial killers in 1988 with Ressler and Douglas. 

If you like this series, check out these other serial killer TV shows.

More Mindhunter

#9 of 75 on The Best Current TV Shows No One Is Watching #98 of 199 on The Best Shows Currently on the Air #12 of 25 on The Best Current TV Shows You Can Still Catch Up On featuring The Best Episodes of 'Mindhunter'

Is this bingeworthy?
see more on Mindhunter
Evil Genius: the True Story of... is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list Netflix Shows And Movies That Are Based On Real Crimes
Photo:  Netflix

On August 28, 2003, a pizza delivery man walked into a bank in Erie, PA, wearing a bomb collar and carrying a shotgun fashioned into a walking cane. He was captured and told police that he had very little time to follow clues to get the bomb collar off his neck before it exploded.

The four-part docuseries Evil Genius delves into unexpected people and places to determine the true mastermind of this infamous heist. It also asks the question: was the pizza delivery man a willing participant or a fall guy?

More Evil Genius: the True Story of America's Most Diabolical Bank Heist

#8 of 30 on The Best Netflix Original Shows Of 2018, Ranked #1 of 64 on The Best Netflix Original Documentary Series #24 of 72 on The Best Mystery Shows On Netflix #27 of 59 on The Best Netflix Original Documentary Movies

Is this bingeworthy?
see more on Evil Genius: the True Story of America's Most Diabolical Bank Heist
Making a Murderer is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list Netflix Shows And Movies That Are Based On Real Crimes
Photo:  Netflix

Making a Murderer (MAM) follows Steven Avery for more than a decade as the center of two controversial criminal trials. Avery's 1985 conviction for violating and attempting to kill a woman was exonerated, and he made it his life's mission to expose the corruption of the law enforcement agency that put him in prison. Then, in 2007, he was convicted for the 2005 death of a Wisconsin photographer named Teresa Halbach and sentenced to life behind bars.

The series follows Avery's second trial and questions whether the prosecution was misleading in how they presented the evidence gathered against him and his nephew, Brendan Dassey. 

In September 2019, Shawn Rech, director of the documentary Convicting a Murderertold Newsweek that a Wisconsin inmate confessed to taking Halbach's life. The identity of the inmate will remain anonymous until law enforcement can confirm the legitimacy of the confession.

Rech's documentary is an unaffiliated follow-up to MAM that aims to reveal all the evidence the original series left out. Rech said they have "uncovered an unfathomable amount of information and evidence that is leading [them] to the truth," including the anonymous confession, and that he feels a responsibility to keep investigators informed. 

More Making a Murderer

#49 of 252 on The Best Netflix Original Series #7 of 18 on The Most Exciting Reality TV Shows in 2019 #6 of 106 on The Best Documentary Series & TV Shows featuring 20 Reasons Why Everyone's Crushing on Dean Strang

Is this bingeworthy?
see more on Making a Murderer
4
The Keepers
The Keepers is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list Netflix Shows And Movies That Are Based On Real Crimes
Photo:  Netflix

Sister Catherine Cesnik disappeared while out shopping in Baltimore, MD, on November 7, 1969. Her body was found on January 20, 1970. The Keepers investigates her death and explores several incidents that may be related. The search reveals a pattern of sexual abuse at the Catholic school where Cesnik taught that the sister might have threatened to expose.

The series explores a confession from a gay neighbor who later committed suicide and gives details on the only living suspect. It also follows a group of women seeking justice for the sexual abuse they suffered at the hands of the people of faith who were supposed to be educating them.

More The Keepers

#22 of 106 on The Best Documentary Series & TV Shows #3 of 64 on The Best Netflix Original Documentary Series #44 of 72 on The Best Mystery Shows On Netflix #4 of 7 on The Best Cult Documentary Series

Is this bingeworthy?