17 TV Show Protagonists Who Were Overshadowed By A Side Character 

Alexandra Plesa
Updated August 24, 2017 22.8k votes 4.4k voters 65.4k views 17 items

List Rules Vote up the shows whose side characters you loved more than the so-called leads.

Great lead TV characters aren’t born, they’re made. You know them by their tragic backstories, kickass introduction scenes, unique quirks, and triumphant redemption arcs. Writers write leads characters in such a way that viewers want to root for them and give them supporting players to do just that – support. These characters will sometimes have their own compelling arcs, but most often they take a back seat to the protagonist, providing guidance, friendship, mentorship, or comedic relief as assigned. 

Once in a blue moon though, a show features a secondary character who totally steals the spotlight. It might be because the lead is a jerk, or is boring, or simply because the side character is played with more dynamism than the lead. In these cases a supporting character can move into more of a co-star if the audience attention pushes creators to give them more screen time. In some cases, a show featuring an ensemble may just naturally have one character shine brighter than others. 

Here are a few examples where a show's lead was totally eclipsed by a more interesting side character.

Orange Is the New Black ... is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list 17 TV Show Protagonists Who Were Overshadowed By A Side Character
Photo:  Orange Is the New Black/Netflix

Remember when this Netflix show revolved around Piper Chapman's misadventures in prison? What a long way we’ve come. While it later became clear that the creators were using Piper to provide viewers with a more relatable entry point into Litchfield, she was incredibly bland in the beginning and hasn’t done much to redeem herself as a character since. She has never been as interesting as her fellow inmates. Which account for why Orange Is the New Black shifted from being about Piper, to being a strong ensemble show allowing all of its strong side characters thorough backstories and continues story lines. Along the way, it transformed into a much more compelling series.

More Orange Is the New Black 

#9 of 265 The Best Female-Led TV Shows #3 of 128 The Best Current Dramatic TV Showsfeaturing The Best Characters on Orange Is the New Black, Ranked

How I Met Your Mother is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list 17 TV Show Protagonists Who Were Overshadowed By A Side Character
Photo:  How I Met Your Mother/CBS

Of course, on this show, it’s not difficult for almost every character to eclipse the bland and often obnoxious Ted Mosby. The show's basic premise - the story of Ted's many wrong turns on the path to finding his eventual spouse - set Ted up for failure as an interesting character. After all, the show ends when Ted meets the future mother of his children, so his character is all but assured to make iffy choices. Not surprisingly, it's Barney Stinson who happily steps in to take the spotlight and be the strong character the show needs. 

Without his fate already set in the way Ted's is, Barney is allowed more range of emotion and even depth. He may be a womanizer, but he's allowed more character development than Ted over the whole series. Ted's always the victim (in his own mind) and Barney is so emotionally detached as to be optimistic. Barney just makes for better TV. Nothing drives home the point more than the fan outrage at the characters' eventual fates, and that, ideally, they would have been swapped.

More How I Met Your Mother 

#27 of 779 The Best TV Shows to Binge Watch #125 of 594 The Best TV Theme Songs of All Timefeaturing Legendary 'How I Met Your Mother' Fan Theories

Dallas is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list 17 TV Show Protagonists Who Were Overshadowed By A Side Character
Photo:  Dallas/CBS

Dallas was supposed to be centered around star-crossed lovers from warring Texas oil families. The show started off focusing on Bobby Ewing's and Pamela Barnes's love story as they dealt with their warring families. Then along came J. R. Ewing, a character everyone loved to hate. He was so popular and beloved that he soon became central to many of the series' biggest storylines, including the infamous "Who Shot J. R.?" plot line that basically invented the TV show cliffhanger.

More Dallas 

#204 of 281 The Best Cult TV Shows of All Time #74 of 594 The Best TV Theme Songs of All Timelisted on Longest Running US Soap Operas

New Girl is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list 17 TV Show Protagonists Who Were Overshadowed By A Side Character
Photo:  New Girl/FOX

Jessica Day is very much the eponymous "new girl" of New Girl, but no one would have expected from the show's pilot that her roommates would become the real reason fans tuned in each week. Jess is adorable, but with friends as memorable as Schmidt, Nick, and Winston, the competition for best character is pretty stiff. So while Season 1 focuses mostly on Jess and her new living situation, eventually the show has gone on to give the focus to the guys. All of the show's characters have a sort of naive quality to them, but Jess's blind optimism makes her rather drab compared to the more dramatically inclined dudes she lives with. 

More New Girl 

#251 of 594 The Best TV Theme Songs of All Time #17 of 265 The Best Female-Led TV Showsfeaturing The Best Seasons of 'New Girl'