In the real world, college is a time of major transition and change. On television shows where the central characters go to college, the transition theme is also common... and the results aren't always pretty. In fact, there are many once-great teen dramas that went to college and became awful.
It's tricky business to insert the college dynamic into a television show that previously focused on high school, and it must be done with great finesse. Not only are there new people, settings, and situations to contend with, but the core of the show – the characters, the depth and humor, the overall storytelling arc of the series – must remain true to its original spirit. Some shows were able to do this successfully, but the worst series set in college crashed and burned.
More than a few great TV shows that got bad in college didn't survive the change and were canceled. But they make for morbidly fascinating viewing nonetheless. These TV shows that fell victim to the college years often tried to shoehorn their characters into new settings and circumstances, and it just didn't work.
Beverly Hills, 90210 doesn't set out to be a realistic show; it's more of a soap opera with really pretty, pampered teenagers going through '90s drama and trauma. But when the central characters go off to college, a series that always flirts with believability takes a dive straight into the realm of the absurd.
Not only do most of the characters attend the same college (California University, in case you forget where the series takes place), but they share the same classes and the same close relationships. It's basically West Beverly Hills High set at California University. Also, major cast changes and ridiculous storylines (Andrea is knocked up! Kelly is a drug addict!) don't help.
Actors: Jason Priestley, Shannen Doherty, Luke Perry
Number of Seasons: 10
Also Rankedsee more on Beverly Hills, 90210
Saved by the Bell: The College Years mercifully lasted just one season. It's basically the same show as Saved by the Bell, except set at California University and featuring a dorm monitor instead of a principal.
While Saved by the Bell isn't art, it has an appeal the college years totally lack. And it's unforgivable that both Lisa Turtle and Jessie Spano aren't series regulars – or perhaps they're lucky.
Actors: Mark-Paul Gosselaar, Tiffani Thiessen, Dustin Diamond
Number of Seasons: 1
Also Rankedsee more on Saved by the Bell: The College Years
Transplanting the Boy Meets World characters into a college setting uproots them from the familiar surroundings and situations the series was built around. Ironically, it turns out that actually allowing Cory and his friends to meet the world causes the show to suffer.
Why does Mr. Feeny follow them to college? Why is the off-campus housing so gigantic? And what is up with that weird student center? There are some noticeable inconsistencies as well, which just makes the college experience that much clunkier.
Actors: Ben Savage, Rider Strong, William Daniels
Number of Seasons: 7
Also Rankedsee more on Boy Meets World
At the beginning, Glee is fresh, inventive, and funny. By the time it becomes necessary for the central characters to attend college, the show's spark is starting to dim considerably, and the transition only dampens it further.
Outside the confines of Mr. Schue's choir room, the Glee characters suddenly become much harder to watch. They morph into bundles of contradictions, and the show starts to feel like a bizarre parody of itself. Even hardcore fans agree this show lasts way longer than it should.
Actors: Lea Michele, Jane Lynch, Matthew Morrison
Number of Seasons: 4
#39 on The Best Dramedy TV Seriessee more on Glee