April 4, 2022 28.8k votes 9.5k voters 200.5k views
Voting Rules
Vote up the most irritating plot holes in 'Twilight'.
Although Kristen Stewart and Robert Pattinson have clearly moved on from their infamous Twilight years, others HAVE NOT. People still love, hate, and love to hate this franchise just as much as they did when it was released.
Below are a few plot holes that fans have pointed out about the Twilight saga. Vote up your favorites!
Victoria Goes To The Prom In 'Twilight,' But There's No Chance She'd Go Unnoticed, Especially Since Edward Would Smell Her And Can Literally Read Minds
Edward would smell a different vampire there. You're also telling me Victoria had enough self control to not murder any of the highschoolers? And also no one in their year questioned who this random red eyed lady was, even though they all obsessed over Bella because their town is that small and boring?
James knew that Bella was a "pet" of the Cullens. He was also told that the Cullens kept a permanent residence in the area.
So Edward reads his mind in the baseball field, and says something like.... "I saw in his mind, the hunt is his obsession. He'll never stop chasing you......"
The sheer fact that they didn’t just fight in the meadow. Seven against three is good odds special if you take into account Emmett’s strength, Jasper’s experience and Edward and Alice’s gifts.
3,009 votes
4
2,998 VOTES
Edward Should've Been Able To Tell That Bella Was Pregnant WAY Before She Told Him
Edward Cullen has TWO. TWO. Medical degrees. He has a vampire’s sense of smell.
Bella has all the classic symptoms of pregnancy, including, but in no particular order:
•cravings
•increased sleep habits
•increased libido
•weird dreams
•missed period
•morning sickness
You’re telling me Bella noticed she was pregnant because she got morning sickness before Edward realized her hormones smelled differently or that she had any other odd behaviors? Not to mention, if Renesmee was moving and everything already, she would have some form of a heartbeat. Edward can hear Bella’s like it’s a drum in the room, so wouldn’t he hear that, too?
2,998 votes
5
2,078 VOTES
Why Would The Cullens Not Consider Victoria A Threat After Killing James? She Helped Him Track Bella And That WAS Her Mate They Killed
[How did the]Cullens didn’t think Victoria would be a threat after they killed James! Victoria and James were mates! Basically any vampire would want revenge for the death of their mate in some way (except Carlisle if Esme was killed… but the other Cullens would and would probably get revenge for her in some way).
2,078 votes
6
2,104 VOTES
Why Would They Go To The Trouble Of Having Jacob Take Bella Up The Mountain To Cover Her Scent, But Have Edward Follow Her Anyways - Leaving An Obvious Scent Trail That DOES Get Picked Up?
In Eclipse they go through all the horrors and traumas of getting Jacob to drag Bella up the mountain... and then Edward goes flying up there after her, which is the biggest bloody giveaway in history!
It is less predictable in the books that it’d go wrong I suppose, as at that point they don’t realise that the newborns coming for Bella has anything to do with Edward, so no reason to think anyone would take the trouble to track Edward’s scent, but you’d think they’d have worked it out or at least suspected! Why else would a whole vampire army be all hunting one random human? Not a huge leap to assume it has something to do with Edward. Bella even suggests it to Edward but he still seems completely blindsided when V&R turn up, which is just unbelievable.
