Graveyard Shift

The Most Underrated Horror Films Of The Last 10 Years 

Orrin Grey
Updated November 8, 2019 1.4k votes 549 voters 18.5k views 14 items

List Rules Vote up the movies that need more attention.

Plenty of horror movies have come out in the last decade, but not all of them get the attention that they deserve. Sure, there are tentpole blockbusters like It or The Conjuring, not to mention indie darlings that receive plenty of press like The WitchIt Follows, or Hereditary. But there have been many underrated scary movies of the 2010s that have flown under the radar of all but the most dedicated of horror fans. Even some critically acclaimed horror movies never got the attention they deserved.

Just because they aren't talked about quite as much, though, doesn't mean that these films are any less thrilling, terrifying, or thought-provoking than their more popular brethren. They may have been the victim of poor marketing or simple bad luck, but for whatever reason, these films didn't get quite the same buzz as some of their contemporaries. They're still worth checking out, though, especially for adventuresome horror fans who want some of the best and most underlooked films that the decade had to offer. For you, here are some of the most underrated horror movies of the 2010s!

Grave Encounters is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list The Most Underrated Horror Films Of The Last 10 Years
Photo: Tribeca Film

Found-footage horror movies and ghost movies have both been extremely popular over the course of the last decade - but they also both get kind of a bad rap among horror connoisseurs as being samey films made to appeal to the least-common denominator. At a glance, Grave Encounters looks like it'll be exactly that - a found-footage dark ride about the crew of a ghost hunting reality show who explore an abandoned mental hospital with a dark history, where they'll encounter plenty of kohl-eyed figures.

And, certainly, it has plenty of that to offer. But Grave Encounters also does things that most of its siblings don't dare, such as messing with time and space in ways that are genuinely disconcerting and reminiscent of more typically thoughtful fare like Picnic at Hanging Rock or the book House of Leaves.

Actors: Alex Sander, Merwin Mondesir, Mackenzie Gray, Juan Riedinger, Fred Keating, + more

Released: 2011

Directed by: Stuart Ortiz, Colin Minihan


More Grave Encounters 

#343 of 784 The Best Horror Movies Of All Time #5 of 86 The Most Horrifying Found-Footage Movies #2 of 46 The Best Horror Movies About Hospitals and Mental Asylums

American Mary is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list The Most Underrated Horror Films Of The Last 10 Years
Photo: Xlrator Media

Sister act directing duo Jen and Sylvia Soska, who have recently remade David Cronenberg's Rabid, first exploded onto the genre scene with their 2012 black comedy horror film American Mary. Though it immediately earned them a name in extreme horror circles, American Mary still remains under-seen by the wider horror world. In it, Katharine Isabelle (of the Ginger Snaps series) plays a medical student who, in desperate need of funds, finds herself drawn into the world of extreme body modification.

Unfortunately, she is also the victim of a terrible assault from the doctors and mentors who are in charge of her residency, which leads her to a grisly revenge and into a cat-and-mouse game with the police. With a 60% at Rotten Tomatoes, the Critics Consensus says American Mary "utilizes pitch-black humor and striking visuals to deliver gory, freaky thrills for body-horror enthusiasts."

Actors: Katharine Isabelle, Antonio Cupo, Paul Anthony, David Lovgren, Jen Soska, + more

Released: 2012

Directed by: Soska sisters, Jen Soska, Sylvia Soska


More American Mary 

#608 of 784 The Best Horror Movies Of All Time #18 of 31 The Best Horror Movies About Evil Doctors and Surgeons #9 of 20 The Scariest Horror Movies With Twins

Absentia is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list The Most Underrated Horror Films Of The Last 10 Years
Photo: Phase Four Films

Director Mike Flanagan has made quite a career for himself by directing Netflix's mini-series version of The Haunting of Hill House, not to mention Stephen King adaptations Gerald's Game and Doctor Sleep. But one of his earliest horror film entries still remains under-seen, in spite of being part of what started his career in the industry.

The film follows Tricia and her sister, Callie. Tricia's husband has been missing for seven years, and she and her sister gradually begin to suspect his disappearance, along with those of many other people in the area, has something to do with a tunnel in front of her house. Just as Tricia is having her husband declared passed in absentia, he abruptly shows back up, bloody and barefoot, and surprised that anyone else can see him.

Of course, things only get freakier from there, as Flanagan showcases some of the skills that have made him a major name in the horror field in the years since.

Actors: Doug Jones, Ian Gregory, Justin Gordon, Katie Parker, Brian Normoyle, + more

Released: 2011

Directed by: Mike Flanagan


More Absentia 

#23 of 23 The Best Cosmic Horror Movies That Will Warp Your Mind #121 of 144 The Best Supernatural Horror Movies, Ranked #425 of 515 The Scariest Movies Ever Made

Green Room is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list The Most Underrated Horror Films Of The Last 10 Years
Photo: A24

Jeremy Saulnier's story of a punk-rock band trapped by white supremacists unfortunately feels more topical with each passing day. It's also notable for its claustrophobic setting, intense action, and powerful performances. After all, it's not every day that you get to see Captain Picard himself, Sir Patrick Stewart, play a skinhead. 

When the film's band, the Ain't Rights, find themselves playing a gig at an out-of-the-way venue in Pacific Northwest, they quickly realize they're in trouble when they notice the place is full of skinheads. That doesn't stop them from playing a cover of "Nazi Punks F*ck Off" by the Dead Kennedys, though. It isn't until the show is over that things take a turn for the fatal. The band is in the green room when they witness a slaying - and the leader of the skinheads decides to take them all out to keep them from talking.

The result is a brutal, nail-biting flick that is also one of late lead actor Anton Yelchin's last film roles.

Actors: Anton Yelchin, Imogen Poots, Alia Shawkat, Joe Cole, Callum Turner, + more

Released: 2016

Directed by: Jeremy Saulnier


More Green Room 

#622 of 784 The Best Horror Movies Of All Time #58 of 137 The Very Best Movies of 2016, Ranked #7 of 15 Horror Movies That Keep You On The Edge Of Your Seat From Start To Finish, Ranked