• Total Nerd

15 Underrated Robin Williams Performances That Remind Us Why We Love Him

List RulesVote up the Robin Williams performances that deserve more love.

You might not think there could be too many underrated Robin Williams performances, given how universally beloved the late actor was. Remember, though - he not only made movies for several decades, but also worked across just about every genre you can image, except for the Western. Few performers have had the kind of career breadth that he did.

It's easy to appreciate his Oscar-winning turn in Good Will Hunting, or his blockbuster work in Mrs. Doubtfire, or the legendary vocal performance he gave in Disney's Aladdin. Those are just a few of his most beloved performances. Plenty of others were just as interesting - they just either weren't properly appreciated at the time or they've been overshadowed by his biggest works. Each of the following roles he played offers a chance to see one of our greatest-ever movie stars showcasing a different side of his immense talent.

Which of these Robin Williams performances is the most underrated? Your votes will determine the answer.

  • Williams was mesmerizing when he was in full-on manic mode, but he knew there was power in going the complete opposite direction, too. He did just that in One Hour Photo, playing an introverted, mentally unstable person to captivating effect. Because the performance is so different from what we expect, the unhinged nature of the character is magnified.

    That character is Seymour Parrish, a guy who works at a photo developing stand. He commits the ultimate no-no, going through the pictures people bring in. When Seymour becomes obsessed with the photos of one particular family, he crosses a line into stalking behavior. Hidden beneath thinning hair and big glasses, Williams understood that the further he pulled inward, the more disturbing Seymour would be. It works. You'd never think that lovable Robin Williams could thoroughly creep you out, but he does.

    • Actors: Robin Williams, Connie Nielsen, Clark Gregg, Michael Vartan, Gary Cole
    • Released: 2002
    • Directed by: Mark Romanek
    161
    27
    Underrated?

    #74 of 245 The Best Psychological Thrillers of All Time#22 of 139 The Best Movies You Never Want To Watch Again#46 of 183 The Best and Scariest Psychological Thrillers of All Time

  • The Birdcage is an American remake of the very funny French classic La Cage aux Folles. The original is more restrained in its humor, but that's okay because Williams is at his peak doing the kind of frenzied comedy his fans love. He plays Armand, the gay owner of a drag club in Miami. When his son becomes engaged to the daughter of a very conservative Republican senator (Gene Hackman), Armand pretends to be straight, going to great lengths to hide his relationship with Albert (Nathan Lane). 

    The story is very much a farce, and Williams pumps it full of energy. When straight actors play gay characters, there's a tendency to teeter into stereotype. The actor definitely goes broad with his performance, yet it's never mocking or insulting. The whole tone of The Birdcage is wild and over-the-top, so his fast-paced antics fit right in. In other words, he's hilarious without ever making Armand feel like a caricature.

    • Actors: Robin Williams, Gene Hackman, Hank Azaria, Calista Flockhart, Nathan Lane
    • Released: 1996
    • Directed by: Mike Nichols
    170
    40
    Underrated?

    #70 of 252 The Funniest '90s Movies#321 of 1,436 The Most Rewatchable Movies#151 of 929 The All-Time Greatest Comedy Films

  • Jumanji remains a popular movie with '90s kids, and it's found a new generation of fans thanks to the Dwayne Johnson/Kevin Hart revival. That said, the quality of Robin Williams's work is often overshadowed by the visual effects and action scenes. The truth is that the movie wouldn't work if he wasn't so good in it. 

    As Alan Parrish, a guy who has been trapped inside a magic board game for two decades, Williams is the heart and soul of the picture. He was shrewd enough to know that the CGI animals running amok would provide a lot of laughter. Therefore, he pulls back a little bit, capturing the bewilderment Alan feels in returning to a world that has dramatically changed, yet not going too broad with it. Had he tried to compete with the wildlife, Jumanji would have gone into overload. By modulating his performance, the movie hits all the right notes to deliver nonstop fun.

    • Actors: Robin Williams, Bonnie Hunt, Kirsten Dunst, Bradley Pierce, Bebe Neuwirth
    • Released: 1995
    • Directed by: Joe Johnston
    134
    24
    Underrated?

    #46 of 440 The Best Movies Of The 1990s#186 of 552 The Greatest Epic Movies Ever Made#90 of 381 The Best Movies Based On Books

  • What Dreams May Come is not an easy film to watch. In fact, it can be a pretty depressing experience. And yet, it's totally worth doing because Williams's superb performance helps give it a real punch. His character, Chris Nielsen, perishes in a car accident. He goes to heaven, where an angel guides him through a beautiful afterlife. The scenario changes when Chris's distraught wife takes her own life and is sent to hell. Determined to rescue her, he ventures into hell, too, and what he finds is terrifying.

    Obviously, a guy would have to seriously love his wife to put himself through that. This is the quality Williams brings to the film. His makes Chris's passion so genuine that we believe he'd sacrifice a peaceful eternity in order to save her. What Dreams May Come works on your emotions, so have a box of tissues nearby when you watch it. 

    • Actors: Robin Williams, Cuba Gooding, Annabella Sciorra, Max von Sydow, Jessica Brooks Grant
    • Released: 1998
    • Directed by: Vincent Ward
    113
    23
    Underrated?

    #427 of 1,195 Every Oscar Winning Film Ever#326 of 781 The Greatest Chick Flicks Ever Made#256 of 375 'Old' Movies Every Young Person Needs To Watch In Their Lifetime