997 voters

18 Incredibly Weird Tumblr Subcultures You've Never Heard About

Updated June 14, 2019 5.8k votes 997 voters 58.8k views18 items

List RulesVote up the weirdest Tumblr-niches that make the least sense to you.

The Internet is a beautiful place that is home to a vast array of bizarre subreddits, weird YouTube videos, and - perhaps the greatest of them all - weird Tumblr tags. There’s nothing more fun than going down a rabbit hole of strange Tumblr subcultures after finishing a bottle of Trader Joe’s pinot noir and exploring the vast world of weird that exists within the CSS that makes up much of the blogging platform.

But what's the weirdest thing on Tumblr? Is it the subculture of people who believe that they have a fictional character living inside their brains? Or is it the group of people who believe that the guys from Supernatural are in a secret relationship and have been sending coded messages about it to their fans? Before we get carried away here, it’s important to remember that what’s weird to you may not be that weird to someone else - but that being said, here are some of the weirdest things on Tumblr.

  • 1


    Photo: YouTube

    If there were to be a place for people who harbor a fascination with mass shooters, it would be Tumblr. Fanblogs have popped up around Aurora shooter James Holmes, Dylan Roof, and the Columbine Shooters Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold. A few Columbiners who spoke to Vice even admitted to having violent and sometimes suicidal thoughts, although it should be noted that they do not advocate murder. One Columbiner said, "[They] didn't represent the whole true crime community, [and] I don't represent the whole true crime community." This is definitely one of the most unsettling Tumblr subcultures, but it should be noted that many Columbiners are in their teens, and flirting with extremely dark subject matter is something that teenagers have always done - it's just that they haven't always had Tumblr. 

    Is this weird?
  • 2


    Photo: knottyboy / flickr / CC-BY 2.0

    Have you ever wondered what it would be like to have a god or goddesses as your spouse? Well, the folks over on the Godspouse Tumblr know exactly what it's like. According to the Godspouses, "Godspousing and god-consorting definitely differs from person to person, but the common denominator is being in an intimate, likely romantic, relationship with a deity." However, that doesn't mean that these #Godspouses have a direct line to the divine. "Divination plays a large role in this. I like to equate it to having a very… VERY long distance relationship, with both of you being on islands with shoddy connection. This, of course, means that miscommunication is a very real threat, and one that has to be combated at all times."

    Is this weird?
  • 3


    Photo: when_night_falls / flickr / CC-BY-ND 2.0

    Otherkin are people who believe that they were not just born in the wrong body, but that they're something inhuman. Otherkin have been around since the early '70s, but their numbers really exploded once Tumblr offered them a space to discuss life as an elf, forest sprite, dragon, etc. The problem with going to Tumblr for otherkin information is that there are a substantial number of trolls - Internet trolls, not just people who believe that they are trolls - who claim to be everything from Eva Braun to a tube of toothpaste.

    Is this weird?
  • 4

    Living Dolls

    Photo: YouTube

    Living dolls are a subculture made up mostly of women and some men who use a combination of cosmetic surgery, diet, and makeup to make themselves look like dolls - picture large eyes, big lips, and an airbrushed-looking complexion. While many people believe that the group has an obscure Barbie-fetish, Olga Oleinik - one the most popular living dolls - insists that there's more of a fantasy thing in the mix: "I've never aimed to look like Barbie. People call us this [any]way. I have more of a space or fantasy image."

    The oddest part of the living-doll Tumblr culture is its crossover with "hypnosis" blogs where living dolls are either hypnotized into becoming dolls, or into doing sexy stuff. Have fun, kids.

    Is this weird?