4.4k voters

Which Horror Movie Isn't As Scary As Everyone Says?

Updated July 23, 2019 41.2k votes 4.4k voters 29.0k views15 items

List RulesVote up the horror films that made you yawn instead of shriek; vote down those that made you shiver.

Rosemary's Baby, The Exorcist, The Shining: They're all classic films with the sole goal of making the viewer's skin crawl. The most celebrated horror movies don't skimp on scares, but the focus is always on the characters. Horror auteur James Wan once succinctly stated, "If you don’t create characters you care about, then it doesn't matter how great the scares you come up with are, you just don’t care about it." Without good characters, the scares fall flat and a wave of disinterest washes over the audience. But when a film has well-rounded characters with whom the audience can truly sympathize, those same moments can chill them to the bone. 

When we asked the Ranker audience which horror films didn't live up to expectations, several of the responses echoed that same sentiment. However, there are also stone-cold viewers in the comment section who think Hereditary is a leisurely Sunday walk in the park.

  • The Exorcist1

    "The Exorcist. I can't watch it without falling asleep."

    More The Exorcist 

    Did A Malevolent Spirit Actually Curse 'The Exorcist' From The Get-Go?The Story Of Roland Doe Inspired The Exorcist – But It's Way More Terrifying Than The Movie

  • It2

    "The original It."

    More It 

    Horrifying Things That Happened In The Book 'IT' Way Too Awful for the MoviesHow The Makers Of The '90s 'It' Miniseries Managed To Scare An Entire Generation

  • The Conjuring 23

    "The Conjuring 2. Not scary at all. It was actually very predictable to me."

  • Paranormal Activity4

    "Paranormal Activity. OMG, that was so awful I threw popcorn at the screen to entertain myself."

    More Paranormal Activity 

    #18 of 67 The Best Demonic Possession Movies#8 of 20 Horror Movies That Originally Had Much Darker Endings

  • The Shining5

    "The Shining, I say this on a personal level lol just because I'd be bored in the hotel and I would be tormenting Johnny hahaha."

    More The Shining 

    Fan Theories About 'The Shining' We Can't Stop Thinking About16 Utterly Bizarre Things You Didn't Know About The Shining

  • Pet Sematary6

    "Pet Sematary, the book, freaked me out. The movie was cheesy and awful. Glad I read the book first because the movie would have ruined it."

    More Pet Sematary 

    Real Burial Grounds And Locations That Could Have Inspired 'Pet Sematary'#140 of 541 The Greatest Guilty Pleasure Movies

  • It7


    "The new It."


    Hilarious Interviews With The Cast Of 'IT' That Will Have You Laughing Like A ClownEvery Time Pennywise Was Hidden In The Background Of The 'It' Movies

  • The Grudge8

    "When people were tripping about The Grudge and I was just like uhhhh ok lol."

    More The Grudge 

    #3 of 15 Non R-Rated Horror Movies As Scary As Anything#49 of 114 The Best Horror Movie Franchises

  • The Exorcism of Emily Rose9

    "The... [Exorcism] of Emily Rose."

    More The Exorcism of Emily Rose 

    #226 of 275 The Best Movies Based On True Stories#11 of 20 20 Horrifying Crime Movies Whose True Stories Are Way More Terrifying

  • It Follows10

    "Recently finally watched It Follows and I have never been so disappointed in a movie. Was absolute garbage."

    More It Follows 

    #21 of 47 The Best Horror Movies About Virus Outbreaks#53 of 114 The Best Intelligent Horror Movies

  • Freddy Vs. Jason11

    "Freddy vs. Jason... I laughed continually in the theater because I had just watched The Simpsons 'Tree House of Horror.'" 

    More Freddy vs. Jason 

    #25 of 105 The Best Horror Movie Sequels#164 of 722 The Best Horror Movies Of All Time

  • Rosemary's Baby12

    "Rosemary's Baby. That movie can cure insomnia."

    More Rosemary's Baby 

    All The Spooky Evidence That Rosemary’s Baby Is, In Fact, A Cursed Movie#723 of 1,189 Every Oscar Winning Film Ever

  • Hereditary13

    "Hereditary. Just a disappointment and DEFINITELY not 'this generation's Exorcist.'"

    More Hereditary 

    Ari Aster's Gutting Horror Film 'Hereditary' May Have Been Just As Scary Behind The ScenesBehind The Scenes Of The Infamous Car Decapitation From 'Hereditary'

  • Veronica14


    "Veronica definitely was a fail on scare factor (typing while drunk and nailing it)."

  • The Witch15

    The Witch

    "[The] Witch from a couple years ago. Total waste of time."