Total Nerd
3.3k voters

Who Would Star In 'Goodfellas' If It Were Cast Today?

Updated June 8, 2020 29.0k votes 3.3k voters 83.7k views14 items

List RulesVote up the actors you think would make perfect Goodfellas.

Martin Scorsese's Goodfellas is a gangster classic. The 1990 film is one of the most influential contributions to the genre, and it's hard to imagine the all-star cast with anyone else. The movie features some of the best Italian-American actors to ever grace the screen, and it's remembered as a definitive entry in the Scorsese canon. It might not be quite as renowned as The Godfather, but it's certainly up there. 

So what if Goodfellas was made today? Who could possibly take DeNiro's place as Jimmy Conway? Can anyone pull off Tommy DeVito's high-energy personality like Joe Pesci? It's a question for the ages, and a fun thought experiment nonetheless. What would a dream cast of modern actors look like? This list is an attempt to fill out a modern-day Goodfellas cast. Don't forget to also check out our list of other great shows and movies like Goodfellas!

  • Robert Michael Cannavale (; born May 3, 1970) is an American actor known for various stage, film and television roles, including regular or recurring roles in Third Watch, Boardwalk Empire, Vinyl, Will & Grace and Mr. Robot. Cannavale had a recurring role on the NBC comedy series Will & Grace as Will Truman's long-term boyfriend Officer Vincent "Vince" D'Angelo, for which he won the 2005 Primetime Emmy Award for Outstanding Guest Actor in a Comedy Series and portrayed Gyp Rosetti during the third season of the HBO drama series Boardwalk Empire, for which he won the 2013 Primetime Emmy Award for Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Drama Series. In 2016, he starred in the HBO drama series... more on Wikipedia
    1,707
    280
    Is this good casting?

    More Bobby Cannavale 

    #171 of 258 The Best Marvel Movie Actors Ever#77 of 87 Celebrities Who Should Be A-Listers#1672 of 1,883 The Greatest Actors & Actresses in Entertainment History

  • Franklin Shea Whigham Jr. (born January 5, 1969) is an American actor. He portrayed Elias "Eli" Thompson in the HBO drama series Boardwalk Empire, and also had supporting roles in Kong: Skull Island, Death Note and True Detective. He appeared as Agent Michael Stasiak in Fast & Furious and Fast & Furious 6. ... more on Wikipedia
    1,487
    262
    Is this good casting?
  • Vincent Philip D'Onofrio (; born June 30, 1959) is an American actor, producer, director, and singer.He is known for his roles as Private Leonard "Gomer Pyle" Lawrence in Full Metal Jacket (1987), Wilson Fisk / Kingpin in Daredevil (2015–2018), NYPD Detective Robert Goren in Law & Order: Criminal Intent, Edgar the Bug in Men in Black (1997), and Vic Hoskins in Jurassic World (2015). Among other honors, D'Onofrio is a Saturn Award winner, an Emmy Award nominee and a Jay Award 2018 winner.... more on Wikipedia
    1,781
    682
    Is this good casting?

    More Vincent D'Onofrio 

    #234 of 1,017 The Best Actors in Film History#116 of 187 The Best Living American Actors#128 of 461 The Best TV Actors of All Time

  • Ray Romano - Sonny Bunz
    Photo: HBO / Warner Bros
    Raymond Albert Romano (born December 21, 1957) is an American stand-up comedian, actor and screenwriter. He is best known for his role on the sitcom Everybody Loves Raymond, for which he received an Emmy Award, and as the voice of Manny in the Ice Age film series. He created and starred in the TNT comedy-drama Men of a Certain Age (2009–11). From 2012 to 2015, Romano had a recurring role as Hank Rizzoli, a love interest of Sarah Braverman in Parenthood, and co-starred in the romantic comedy The Big Sick (2017). Romano portrays as Rick Moreweather in the comedy-drama series Get Shorty.... more on Wikipedia
    1,492
    591
    Is this good casting?

    More Ray Romano 

    #81 of 233 The Funniest Stand Up Comedians Of All Time#105 of 339 The Funniest People Of All Time#40 of 45 Celebrities Who Had Weird Jobs Before They Were Famous