Total Nerd

Who Would Star In 'The Princess Bride' If It Were Made Today?  

Zach Seemayer
1.7k votes 230 voters 4.5k views 15 items

List Rules Vote up the actors you'd want to see in a remake of 'The Princess Bride.'

Decades after its release, The Princess Bride is still considered to be one of the greatest romantic fantasy films of all time, featuring an unparalleled sense of fun and adventure had by a stellar cast of brilliant performers who filled their iconic characters with endless charm, depth and humanity. In our age of constant big budget remakes of beloved classics and '80s nostalgia, the time may come when a Princess Bride reboot eventually gets slated for production, and if that happens, the most important thing will be who the filmmakers tap to bring that same on-screen magic that the original a timeless masterpiece.

So who could fill the Westley's (a.k.a. The Dread Pirate Roberts) boots the way Cary Elwes did? It would seem that the brilliant Dan Stevens (of Downton Abbey and The Guest) has all the suave charm, handsomeness and fighting proficiency to bring that character to life. And who has the kind of roguish charm that Mandy Patinkin brought to the master swordsman Inigo Montoya? Look no farther than the incomparable Oscar Isaac, who absolutely excels at playing broken yet charismatic figures with good intentions and murderous ambitions. Check out our fantasy casting for a Princess Bride remake, and vote up the actors you'd most want to see taking on the iconic roles.

Carol Kane is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list Who Would Star In 'The Princess Bride' If It Were Made Today?
Photo:  20th Century Fox/Netflix

Age: 66

Birthplace: Cleveland, Ohio, United States of America

More Carol Kane

#63 of 293 on The Funniest Female Comedians of All Time #24 of 48 on The Best Law & Order SVU Guest Stars #6 of 11 on Here's What Happened To Everyone From 'The Princess Bride' #36 of 50 on Female Celebrities Who Are 5’2"

is this good casting?
see more on Carol Kane
Billy Crystal is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list Who Would Star In 'The Princess Bride' If It Were Made Today?
Photo:  20th Century Fox/FX

Age: 70

Birthplace: Upper East Side, New York City, New York, United States of America

More Billy Crystal

#33 of 363 on The Funniest People of All Time #33 of 96 on The Best SNL Cast Members of All Time #42 of 407 on The Funniest Stand Up Comedians of All Time #5 of 793 on American Public Figures Who Are National Treasures

is this good casting?
see more on Billy Crystal
Kristofer Hivju is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list Who Would Star In 'The Princess Bride' If It Were Made Today?
Photo:  20th Century Fox/HBO

Age: 40

Birthplace: Oslo, Norway

More Kristofer Hivju

#16 of 55 on The Best Game of Thrones Actors #13 of 25 on Game of Thrones Actors and What Their Real Voices Sound Like

is this good casting?
see more on Kristofer Hivju