Charting The Tragic Downfall Of The Simpsons: Why The Show Will Never Be As Good As It Used To Be  

Alex Welch
1.5k votes 240 voters 9.1k views 15 items

List Rules Vote up the reasons why The Simpsons has lost the magic.

When it premiered on FOX in 1989, The Simpsons was unlike any other TV show in history. But over the past few years, fans have been plagued wondering endlessly why The Simpsons isn't as good as it used to be. Is it just that the series has been on the air for so long, or is it because of a wrong direction the show took creatively somewhere along the way?

It's not unfair to wonder why or when did The Simpsons go downhill either, as the series was known for many years in the 1990s as being one of the best shows to ever grace the small screen. But despite making a name for itself for its biting satirical comedy, iconic characters, and brilliant comedic moments, the series has become - more or less - a shell of its former self.

It's time to investigate and truly delve deep into the reasons behind why The Simpsons has become such an ineffective TV comedy over the years. So here are our reasons for why The Simpsons isn't good anymore.

Almost None Of The Original Staff Is Still Around
Almost None Of The Origi... is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list Charting The Tragic Downfall Of The Simpsons: Why The Show Will Never Be As Good As It Used To Be
Photo:  FOX

Building off of the last point, anyone who knows about the creative team behind The Simpsons in the late 1980s and 90s knows how integral that specific team was to shaping the vision of the show.

As such there's an obvious correlation between the disintegration of that original team, and how different the tone and direction of The Simpsons is now compared to how it was in its original seasons. That goes father than just original creators/developers, James L. Brooks, Matt Groening, and Sam Simon no longer being involved in any real capacity too.

In addition to those three men, The Simpsons had a stellar writer's team in its early seasons, which included the likes of Conan O'Brien, Greg Daniels, Bill Oakley, and more. Now, in the show's 28th season, only three of those original writers remain. This means that was once one of the most effective and collaborative writer teams in TV history, is now all but completely gone.

Agree or disagree?
The Jokes Aren't As Complex
The Jokes Aren't As Comp... is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list Charting The Tragic Downfall Of The Simpsons: Why The Show Will Never Be As Good As It Used To Be
Photo:  FOX

In this excellent video essay by Super Eyepatch Wolf, he details how the comedy on The Simpsons has grown increasingly less complex or smart over the years. Not only does that mean a lot less beats in each of the show's many gags, but also in the removal of many of the jokes' brilliant layers.

Nowadays, The Simpsons is starting to more and more resemble the typical TV comedy that it fought so hard not to be in its early seasons. That's resulted in the repeated use of jokes that often betray the motivations and personalities of the characters as well, and are as far removed from the intellectual nature of the show's original comedic style as possible. 

Whether that means the hiring of a new crew of writers on the series or consulting more with the show's original team, it's clear that The Simpsons has, more or less, lost its comedic way.

Agree or disagree?
It Stopped Being An Effective Satire
It Stopped Being An Effe... is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list Charting The Tragic Downfall Of The Simpsons: Why The Show Will Never Be As Good As It Used To Be
Photo:  FOX

When The Simpsons premiered in 1989, it sparked outrage in the United States, which was basically the best confirmation that The Simpsons had accomplished its original mission that the show could have asked for. The series started out as a completely ruthless satire, directed most notably towards the false depiction of a "traditional" American family. As such, The Simpsons took joy in ripping apart every idea that TV and film had given the general public about the way they were meant to live their lives, and the insidiousness at the heart of many of those myths.

But now, The Simpsons feels like it barely has anything to say. What used to be the angriest show on television, is now one of the most directionless. And aside from some occasional political riffs, The Simpsons has become void of any real messages, or at least, ones that aren't already being said by dozens of other shows on a weekly basis.

Agree or disagree?
The Characters Have Lost Their Way
The Characters Have Lost... is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list Charting The Tragic Downfall Of The Simpsons: Why The Show Will Never Be As Good As It Used To Be
Photo:  FOX

One of the biggest criticisms that The Simpsons has faced in recent years, is how simplified the characters in the series have become. After all, while Homer, Marge, Bart, Lucy, and Lisa were all based on archetypes that audiences were previously familiar with, The Simpsons managed to make them all memorable by taking the time to shade them in with more dimension than other shows or movies usually did.

While Homer was a drunk, lazy, and often violently angry man, he also deeply loved his family and the town of Springfield, which made viewers grow attached to him. Similarly, Bart was an anarchic and rebellious teen who simultaneously caused trouble and suffered through deeply serious internal issues as well.

Now, none of the decisions or jokes that characters make on the show feel in tune with those pre-established emotions and contradictions. Homer has devolved into being the dumb and mean father while Bart often causes trouble just for the sake of causing trouble, rather than the trouble he causes being the manifestation of his own inner conflicts.

Agree or disagree?