emmys Arguably the Worst Emmy Winners of All Time, Ranked  

Lisa Waugh
1.8k votes 565 voters 11.2k views 17 items

For each astounding, inspiring Emmy-winning actor that makes us laugh, cry, and feel real, human emotions watching their performances, there are an equal number of Emmy-winners who definitely don't deserve the honor. Some of these Emmy-winning actors were given bad roles, while others were just not as great as other nominees. Whatever the case, we've put together a list of the worst Emmy winners that really don't deserve the award they received for their work.

Louis C.K. probably wasn't happy after losing to Jon Cryer in 2012, but that kind of choice reveals a lot about Emmy voters. When an out-of-the-blue nominee wins an Emmy, certain questions tend to arise, such as: Do Emmy voters have cable? Are they giving their ballots to non-humans? Why William Shatner, and why now? The worst Emmy winners betray viewers' trust, and let down die-hard fans of other performances.

Some of these Emmy wins feel completely out of place. Kiefer Sutherland over Martin Sheen? Behind the Candlelabra over Top of the Lake? Are these worst Emmy winners a result of industry insiders thinking that they know best?

Not agreeing with an Emmy nomination or win doesn’t make the actor or show in question automatically bad. Many times, the worst Emmy wins are simply tone deaf in the context of the year and competition. Or they seem out of step in retrospect.

Vote up the worst Emmy Award winnings below, and be sure to let us know what you think in the comment section.
Jon Cryer is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list Arguably the Worst Emmy Winners of All Time, Ranked
Photo: via Tumblr
1 215 VOTES

Jon Cryer

The Win: Two and a Half Men, Outstanding Lead Actor in a Comedy Series, 2012 .
Who Didn’t Win: Don Cheadle (House of Lies), Louis C.K. (Louie), Larry David (Curb Your Enthusiasm), and Jim Parsons (Big Bang Theory)

Jon Cryer is probably best known and beloved for playing the role of Duckie in Pretty in Pink. But when his win shut out Louis C.K., Larry David, and Alex Baldwin, it was a total crying shame. Many felt that the award was given to Cryer out of sympathy for having to work with Charlie Sheen all those years.

Also Ranked

#44 on The Greatest '80s Teen Stars

163 52
Agree or disagree?
see more on Jon Cryer
Melissa McCarthy is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list Arguably the Worst Emmy Winners of All Time, Ranked
Photo: via Pinterest
2 139 VOTES

Melissa McCarthy

The Win: Mike & Molly, Best Actress in a Comedy Series 2011
Who Didn’t Win: Edie Falco (Nurse Jackie), Tina Fey (30 Rock), Laura Linney (The Big C), Martha Plimpton (Raising Hope), and Amy Poehler (Parks and Recreation)

With so many kick-ass female contenders on this list, it was probably a difficult decision to choose which one should win the Emmy. However, Melissa McCarthy's role on Mike & Molly seemed to lack some of the undeniable feminine power of the other shows. Her character seemed to constantly play into plus-size female comedian stereotypes, and we would have loved to see a little bit more of the confidence and badassery of Tina Fey, Edie Falco, or Amy Poehler for this win. Although McCarthy is an active feminist, and part of the body-positivity movement among women, her role on this show didn't do the real-life version of herself justice.

Also Ranked

#56 on The Funniest People of All Time

#53 on The Best Actresses Working Today

#61 on The Most Trustworthy Celebrities in the World

#50 on The Most Original Comedians

100 39
Agree or disagree?
see more on Melissa McCarthy
Katherine Heigl is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list Arguably the Worst Emmy Winners of All Time, Ranked
Photo: via Imgur
3 166 VOTES

Katherine Heigl

The Win: Grey's Anatomy, Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Drama Series, 2007.
Who Didn’t Win: Lorraine Bracco (The Sopranos), Rachel Griffiths (Brothers & Sisters), Sandra Oh (Grey’s Anatomy), Aida Turturro (The Sopranos), and Chandra Wilson (Grey’s Anatomy

If Shonda Rhimes had a time machine, you can bet your britches that Katherine Heigl would not have an Emmy on her mantel for this particular role. Heigl power-tripped herself out of a career after bad mouthing Grey’s Anatomy and acting like a total diva on set. Although she made Denny's death on the show feel real to all who watched it, her later attitude towards her co-stars in general made us wish the award had been given to someone else.

Also Ranked

#58 on The Greatest Former Child Stars

#84 on The Greatest '90s Teen Stars

#97 on Famous Women You'd Want to Have a Beer With

#94 on Natural Beauties Who Don't Need No Make-Up

111 55
Agree or disagree?
see more on Katherine Heigl
Kevin Costner is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list Arguably the Worst Emmy Winners of All Time, Ranked
Photo: via Imgur
4 134 VOTES

Kevin Costner

The Win: Hatfields & McCoys, Outstanding Lead Actor in a Miniseries or Movie, 2012
Who Didn’t Win: Benedict Cumberbatch (Sherlock), Idris Elba (Luther), Woody Harrelson (Game Change), Clive Owen (Hemingway & Gellhorn), and Bill Paxton (Hatfields & McCoys)

The fact that anyone could ever possibly hope to win over Woody Harrelson, Benedict Cumberbatch, or Idris Elba comes as a complete shock to Emmy watchers. 

Also Ranked

#78 on The Best Actors in Film History

#88 on The Best (Male) Actors Working Today

#68 on The Coolest Actors Ever

#72 on The Greatest Actors Who Have Never Won an Oscar (for Acting)

89 45
Agree or disagree?
see more on Kevin Costner