Whether it's dramatic, heartwarming, or a combination of the two, few things are better than a good love story. The best romance anime push viewers to root for the central couple while keeping them engrossed with a compelling narrative. Unfortunately, not all romantic anime are captivating. Some are just plain terrible.
The worst romance anime series leave viewers hoping the main couple never speak to each other again. These shows are just poorly done, with ugly animation and boring, underdeveloped characters. The storytelling might be subpar, or contain objectionable themes and then fail to treat them with any degree of nuance. Eromanga Sensei, for instance, features a 12-year-old girl who writes adult material for a living, and Diabolik Lovers shows a teenage girl repeatedly assaulted by vampires.
It would be smart to avoid watching these awful "romantic" programs with a partner, unless the goal is to get them to question your idea of romance. In fact, anime fans are probably better off not watching them at all.
The internet has maligned Boku no Pico for years. It's infamous for featuring a romantic and sexual relationship between 15-year-old Pico and 22-year-old Tamotsu. Legally, Pico can't consent to anything with Tamotsu, since the story takes place in Tokyo and the age of consent there is 18. Despite this, Tamotsu repeatedly pressures him into engaging in sexual acts he isn't comfortable with, including forcing him to cross-dress. As if all this weren't bad enough, Pico's character design makes him look much younger his actual age.
While this travesty is technically a hentai, it interrupts its sexual moments with attempts at real romance between the protagonists. However, it doesn't work.
Eiken's claim to fame has less to do with its romantic storyline and more so that many of its female characters have enormous breasts. There's a sixth-grader in the program with EE cups. If that alone isn't enough to dissuade viewers, there's also a bare-bones storyline involving a nerdy, dull male protagonist named Densuke Mifune who is inexplicably surrounded by girls who are supposed to be attractive but aren't, because of the terrible art.
All Densuke wants is to get closer to his crush, Chiharu, but a series of random misunderstandings stops him from making progress. Chiharu is basically a knockoff, depthless version of Hinata Hyuuga - her only traits are being shy and having boobs.
If someone is looking for an anime version of Twilight, Diabolik Lovers is about as close as they're going to get. Yui Komori moves into a mansion that's already inhabited by six vampire brothers. What follows is an onslaught of psychic and sexual assaults on the poor girl.
While it can be somewhat refreshing to see vampires acting like monsters, it's disconcerting to watch Yui react to their brutal behavior with kindness and acceptance. What's worse is watching her start to develop relationships with them, given their complete lack of interest in her well-being at the start of the anime.
#39 on The Best Supernatural Anime
Kodomo no Jikan follows a relationship between a teacher in his early 20s and his 7-year-old student. For many anime fans, this type of relationship is an automatic deal breaker. For others, it depends on the execution; a story that realistically deals with the ramifications of this kind of situation is different from one that glorifies it. Kodomo no Jikan does the latter.
It begins with Rin Kokonoe, an abused child, acting out by attempting to entice her third-grade teacher, Daisuke Aoki. Instead of getting the little girl the help she needs, Aoki eventually comes to reciprocate Rin's feelings for him. The series should end with Aoki in handcuffs and Rin in therapy, but the two officially announce their relationship when Rin turns 16.