1.6k voters

The Worst Super Bowls of All Time

Updated December 22, 2020 4.6k votes 1.6k voters 44.3k views11 items

List RulesVote for the Super Bowls that weren't so super.

Of the many Super Bowls played in NFL history, not all of them have always lived up to the hype that comes with the Big Game. Sure, the Super Bowl ads still sold for millions of dollars and the halftime show may or may not have featured an aging rock star or a memorable moment, but the Super Bowl games themselves (you know, the actual football parts) really blew.

Even though the Super Bowl (the NFL's championship game), technically, matches up the top two teams in the league to vie for the Lombardi Trophy, there have been some real downers. Some were disasters for one team or the other, some were low scoring defensive struggles, and some were such big blowouts that they lacked any kind of on-field excitement.

What were the worst Super Bowls of all time? These are the biggest Super Bowl blowouts, most boring Super Bowl matchups, and even a few were among the highest-scoring Super Bowl ever, but just weren't any fun to watch. Cast your votes below to rank the absolute worst, definitely NOT super, Super Bowls in football history.

  • 1

    Super Bowl XXIV (San Francisco 49ers Beat Denver Broncos)

    Video: YouTube

    One team that didn't have great Super Bowl luck during the '80s? The Denver Broncos. Although they made the Big Game quite a bit during the decade, they failed to ever really compete in one.

    Super Bowl XXIV was no different, as the Broncos couldn't stop the San Francisco 49ers' vaunted offense, getting blown out on the biggest stage and setting an NFL record for the largest point margin in the Super Bowl history.

    Final Score:
    San Francisco 55, Denver 10

    Was this a terrible Super Bowl?
  • 2

    Super Bowl XXVII (Dallas Cowboys Beat Buffalo Bills)

    Video: YouTube

    The first of back-to-back matchups between the Buffalo Bills and the Dallas Cowboys in the Big Game, Super Bowl XXVII proved that the Bills were no match for America's Team.

    After an exciting first quarter that included three touchdowns and a 14-7 Dallas lead, the Cowboys turned it on the remaining three quarters, outscoring the Bills 38-10 and routing them for their first title in 15 years.

    Final Score:
    Dallas 52, Buffalo 17

    Was this a terrible Super Bowl?
  • 3

    Super Bowl XXXV (Baltimore Ravens Beat New York Giants)

    Video: YouTube

    Every once in a while there's a team that is just destined to win the Lombardi Trophy, and after watching Super Bowl XXXV, it was clear that the Baltimore Ravens was that team.

    Boasting one of the most suffocating defenses in the league's history, the Ravens left no doubt that they'd earned that title, burying the New York Giants in decisive fashion, with Baltimore's defensive leader, Ray Lewis, earning game MVP honors for his performance and leadership of his defensive mates.

    Final Score:
    Baltimore 34, New York 7
    Was this a terrible Super Bowl?
  • 4

    Super Bowl XXVIII (Dallas Cowboys Beat Buffalo Bills)

    Video: YouTube

    The rematch between the Buffalo Bills and the Dallas Cowboys in Super Bowl XXVIII was a little prettier than the game they had played just 12 months earlier—but it still ended with Buffalo on the losing end.

    Cleaning up a few mistakes they made in the previous matchup, Buffalo failed to slow down Dallas running back Emmitt Smith, who ran for 132 yards and two touchdowns on his way to winning the game MVP trophy. The game ended a stretch of four-straight Super Bowl losses for Buffalo, as well.

    Final Score:
    Dallas 30, Buffalo 13
    Was this a terrible Super Bowl?