Total Nerd

16 Actresses Who Would Be Perfect As Zatanna 

Joe Donley
Updated June 14, 2019 5.6k votes 865 voters 13.8k views 16 items

List Rules Vote up the actresses you most want to see play Zatanna.

Zatanna Zatara has a rich history in the DC Universe, dating back to her introduction in Hawkman #4 in 1964. She debuted as the daughter of famed Golden Age magical hero Giovanni Zatara. Since then, Zatanna has been at the forefront of many mystical storylines that involve characters across the brand, ranging from Batman to our favorite Hellblazer, John Constantine. She's even appeared in Young Justice and made her live-action debut in a little show called Smallville.

Zatanna was a major character in the 2017 animated film Justice League Dark and, in 2016, Wonder Woman's sword and shield introduced magic to the DCEU in Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice. With the incredibly odd choice of Enchantress as a big bad in Suicide Squad, it seems like the perfect time for Zatanna to make her live-action debut on the silver screen. Check out the best actresses who should play Zatanna!

Serinda Swan is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list 16 Actresses Who Would Be Perfect As Zatanna
Photo: Metaweb (FB)/Fair use

No Zatanna casting list could exist without mentioning Serinda Swan, who has the honor of being the first ever live-action Zatanna, debuting in the Smallville episode "Hex." Swan captures Zatanna's look, personality, and camp onscreen and should be at the top of any casting director's list for the role.

Age: 34

Credits: Smallville

Are they one of the best?
Eliza Dushku is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list 16 Actresses Who Would Be Perfect As Zatanna
Photo: Cinemax

Best known as Echo in Joss Whedon's Dollhouse and Faith in Buffy the Vampire Slayer and Angel, Eliza Dushku oozes the onscreen charisma and nerve needed to accurately portray characters rooted in that comic book hero mentality, like Zatanna.

Age: 38

Credits: Bring It On, Tru Calling, Dollhouse, Buffy The Vampire Slayer

Are they one of the best?

More Eliza Dushku 

#154 of 327 The Best Actresses Working Today #133 of 378 The Best American Actresses Working Today #331 of 940 The Best Actresses in Film History

Lacey Chabert is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list 16 Actresses Who Would Be Perfect As Zatanna
Photo: flickr/CC0

Known to most as Gretchen Wieners from Mean Girls, Lacey Chabert is no stranger to the character. Chabert gave her voice to Zatanna in the shows Young Justice and Justice League Action as well as the video games Injustice: Gods Among Us, Young Justice: Legacy, and Infinite Crisis.

Age: 36

Credits: Mean Girls, Not Another Teen Movie, The Wild Thornberrys, Family Guy

Are they one of the best?

More Lacey Chabert 

Whatever Happened To Lacey Chabert? #212 of 378 The Best American Actresses Working Today #546 of 940 The Best Actresses in Film History

Tatiana Maslany is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list 16 Actresses Who Would Be Perfect As Zatanna
Photo: NBC

If you've watched Orphan Black at all, you know exactly why Tatiana Maslany is here. If you haven't, go watch the first episode and fall in love. Maslany is arguably the most versatile actor in television at the moment and would make an incredible Zatanna considering the sheer range of her talents.

Age: 33

Credits: Orphan Black

Are they one of the best?

More Tatiana Maslany 

#191 of 327 The Best Actresses Working Today #221 of 378 The Best American Actresses Working Today #556 of 940 The Best Actresses in Film History