Toby Cavanaugh

FANS ALSO LIKE

Toby Cavanaugh

He was the stepbrother of Jenna. Toby took the blame for blinding Jenna which led his parents to send him away. This was because Alison had conspired with Jenna to send him away. Toby was thought by his peers to be very creepy. When he returned, he had turned in a handsome boy and had a short relationship with Emily before his death. He was thought to be "A" by the girls causing Emily to panic. He had been refering what he had done to Jenna however not being "A". He was

Toby Cavanaugh IS LISTED ON